When it comes to Underrated Dakota Johnson movies you probably missed, there’s more than enough proof that her talent extends well beyond her well-known portrayal of Anastasia Steele. While many remember Dakota Johnson for her breakout roles or her Hollywood lineage—being the daughter of Melanie Griffith and Don Johnson—she’s built an impressive filmography filled with overlooked performances, showing not just range, but also an unsung emotional depth and passion. Here are five hidden gems you likely did not catch the first time, each worthy of a spot on your watchlist for their unique genres, strong storytelling, and Johnson’s compelling acting.
Beyond the Blockbusters: Johnson’s Film Career Has Range
Many casual movie fans tend to think of Dakota Johnson mainly as the star of blockbuster romance dramas, yet her career is underscored by roles that stretch far outside the mainstream. From quirky thrillers to indie dramas, Johnson has showcased transformative abilities, embracing roles with emotional resonance. While her interviews and offbeat style have earned her a distinctive reputation in Hollywood, her lesser-known projects reveal a willingness to dive deep into diverse characters, hearts, and genres. The following list explores the films that demonstrate her versatility and prove that there’s much more to her than meets the eye.
5. The Peanut Butter Falcon (2019) — Heartfelt Adventure on the Bayou
Inspired by the narrative style and humor of Mark Twain, The Peanut Butter Falcon is a 2019 independent film that blends adventure, realism, and laughter, creating an unforgettable journey. In this touching story, Zack Gottsagen stars as Zak, a young man with Down syndrome who escapes from his care facility to fulfill his dream of becoming a professional wrestler. Along this path, Zak encounters Shia LaBeouf’s character Tyler, a wandering fisherman with a troubled past. Dakota Johnson steps into the role of Eleanor, a compassionate social worker tasked with bringing Zak home.
As Eleanor, Johnson brings empathy and warmth, serving as a stabilizing force amidst the unfolding chaos. Her grounded performance avoids unnecessary theatrics, instead highlighting a softer, emotionally present side. Though Eleanor is not the loudest character, her sincerity anchors the film, reflecting Johnson’s capability to shine in understated roles. These qualities are part of what makes this performance and film a true hidden gem.
The buzzy indie earned more than $23 million at the box office on a relatively small $6 million budget, even capturing audience awards at various film festivals. Despite this, The Peanut Butter Falcon didn’t reach the level of mainstream attention it deserved. Whether due to its tenderhearted story or its position outside blockbuster norms, the film often escapes notice on typical movie rosters. However, its Southern charm, heart, and wit make it a standout for anyone seeking a feel-good, powerful watch.
The Peanut Butter Falcon is currently available to stream on Prime Video in the US.
4. Our Friend (2019) — Story of Sacrifice and Resilience
Our Friend, released in 2019, might not have gathered significant buzz at the box office, but the film offers a profoundly emotional experience. Based on the true story of the Teague family, Johnson portrays Nicole, who receives a cancer diagnosis that tests the resilience of both herself and her husband Matt, played by Casey Affleck. The pair are not alone—Jason Segel appears as Dane, the family’s steadfast friend who commits everything to supporting them during their struggle.
Johnson’s portrayal of Nicole stands out for its maturity and raw emotion. Unlike stereotypical depictions, she brings a complex mix of strength, vulnerability, and authenticity, making Nicole a full, living character rather than just a tragic figure. The pain and joy in her performance echo the trials of real families facing similar struggles.
Despite strong acting from its star-studded cast and a story built around friendship, grief, and love, Our Friend couldn’t overcome box office challenges and a pandemic-affected release, ultimately grossing less than $1 million on a $10 million budget. Still, critics praised the film, and among fans who found it, Johnson’s work is considered a highlight of her career.
For viewers searching for an emotional, cathartic viewing experience that examines love, loss, and the deep bonds of friendship, Our Friend is an underrated option now streaming on Peacock.
3. Bad Times at the El Royale (2018) — A Stylish, Twisted Mystery
Imagine an eerie hotel, perched right on the state line between Nevada and California, with a lineup of suspicious guests and secrets within every room. That’s the setup for Bad Times at the El Royale, a 2018 mystery thriller directed by Drew Goddard. The ensemble cast boasts big names including Jon Hamm, Chris Hemsworth, Jeff Bridges, and Lewis Pullman, adding intrigue to the suspenseful storyline.
In this noir-infused thriller, Dakota Johnson plays Emily Summerspring, an enigmatic, powerful woman whose intentions remain unclear until the final act. Johnson moves away from typecast “good girl” roles, taking on a character full of grit and edge; Emily is fiercely protective, bold, and sometimes dangerous. Her performance disrupts the stereotype, amplifying the tense energy and enabling the film’s plot twists to land with extra force.
Although Bad Times at the El Royale featured non-stop suspense, striking visual style, and major Hollywood talent, it missed financial expectations by just $1 million, pulling in $31 million on a $32 million budget. Perhaps its unique approach and retro mood weren’t mainstream enough for commercial audiences, or maybe it got lost in the crowd during awards season. However, those who watch it now will discover a stylized thriller where Dakota Johnson absolutely commands attention in every scene she appears.
Bad Times at the El Royale can currently be streamed on Hulu in the United States.
2. Beastly (2011) — Johnson’s Early, Scene-Stealing Role
Before Dakota Johnson became a widely recognized star, she took on a small but memorable role in Beastly, a 2011 contemporary spin on Beauty and the Beast. The movie, which stars Alex Pettyfer and Vanessa Hudgens, is set against a backdrop of moody New York City teens, magical transformations, and romantic drama typical of that era’s trendy fantasy franchises.
Johnson appears as Sloan Hagen, the classic mean girl who tries to tempt the story’s cursed protagonist at just the wrong time. Though her role in Beastly is brief, her presence is commanding—showing even in the early days of her film career that she could stand out in a large ensemble cast, making Sloan both captivating and easy to dislike. Johnson’s performance hints at her potential, delivering a bold character with every moment onscreen.
Despite only making a fleeting appearance, Dakota Johnson managed to leave a lasting impression, confirming her knack for impacting even the smaller, supporting roles. Beastly found moderate financial success amid the popularity of fantasy romances, earning over $38 million at the box office against a $17 million production budget. Still, compared to its genre competitors, it didn’t make lasting waves—though today, it remains a guilty pleasure for fans who want to see future stars before they made it big.
The film is currently available to stream on Prime Video.
1. Persuasion (2022) — Austen’s Classic, Reimagined for a Modern Audience
Stepping into period drama through a contemporary filter, Persuasion (2022) offers viewers a reinterpretation of Jane Austen’s beloved novel. Johnson plays Anne Elliot, a reserved yet clever woman torn between societal pressures and rekindled feelings for an old flame. The Netflix production stands apart by embracing modern narration, fourth-wall-breaking commentary, and a frequent dose of self-aware humor in place of classical restraint.
Not all viewers were receptive to the film’s inventive blend—some Austen purists voiced disappointment with its playful approach, while others delighted in its relatable protagonist. Dakota Johnson’s performance as Anne brings emotional complexity, tender vulnerability, and sly wit. The character’s heartbreak and resilience play out in scenes that feel both contemporary and timeless, allowing a classic character to resonate with younger, modern audiences.
Although Persuasion generated online conversation upon release and briefly topped Netflix’s trending lists, it ultimately drew mixed reactions for veering away from the traditional tone of Austen’s writing. The straight-to-streaming release means box office numbers aren’t relevant, but the film is quickly developing a cult following among fans who appreciate a fresh spin on period romance. Johnson’s nuanced portrayal keeps the adaptation engaging and underscores her ability to thrive in unconventional roles.
Persuasion is now streaming for US audiences on Netflix.
Why These Films Deserve a Spot on Your Watchlist
Each title on this list showcases a different facet of Dakota Johnson’s artistry, whether as a nurturing social worker, a complex and resilient partner, a mysterious bad girl, an antagonistic high school queen, or a modern reinterpretation of a literary hero. These performances indicate why Johnson has earned respect beyond her tabloid headlines and blockbuster fare. Although these projects didn’t always achieve box office dominance, they resonate with viewers who enjoy thoughtful storytelling and committed performances.
From The Peanut Butter Falcon’s heartwarming journey to the stylized intrigue of Bad Times at the El Royale and the cultural experiments of Persuasion, Johnson’s filmography is dotted with overlooked masterpieces. For fans eager to experience Underrated Dakota Johnson movies you probably missed, these films offer not only entertainment but a deeper appreciation of an actress unafraid to take creative risks. Consider adding them to your next movie marathon—you might just discover an unexpected favorite.
