James Gunn is reportedly facing new obstacles at DC Studios, with HBO expressing doubts about certain television projects, just as the upcoming Superman film moves toward a more conventional style. These developments suggest Gunn’s original vision is making way for broader appeal, as the DC Universe undergoes significant behind-the-scenes changes.
Superman Reboots With a More Conservative Approach
Recent reports indicate that the new Superman movie, which stands at the center of the DCU reboot, is undergoing sizeable alterations. Initial plans had featured an episodic narrative structure, unfolding over different days of the week. This innovative idea has apparently been set aside after test screenings.
“It sounds like [DC Studios is] playing it a little safe.”
—Jeff Sneider, Insider
These adjustments reinforce earlier rumors pointing to ongoing changes in the editing room, with talk of a possible new composer joining the project. This transition away from creative risk-taking could reflect studio caution, as leadership aims to secure a wider audience following turbulent years at DC. With a single opportunity to regain fan trust, the studio appears to be opting for familiarity over experimentation.
Casting Speculation and Actor Reservations
The Hot Mic podcast also stirred conversation around casting possibilities, specifically referencing Colin Farrell as a potential candidate for the villainous Brainiac. Given the delay of the Sgt. Rock project, Farrell’s schedule may now permit such a commitment. His thorough transformation for The Penguin highlighted his ability to take on demanding DC roles, but fans recall he has openly shared his discomfort with heavy makeup during past projects like The Penguin series.
HBO’s Hesitation Over New DCU TV Content
The disputes do not stop with film. There are signs that HBO is pushing back against some of Gunn’s planned television series set in the DCU.
“HBO [is] blocking Gunn’s ideas for TV shows.”
—Jeff Sneider, Insider
The reported resistance centers on anticipated programs such as Lanterns, Waller, and Booster Gold. Unlike previous efforts that secured HBO’s full backing, such as Watchmen and The Penguin, these titles are encountering skepticism. Given HBO’s reputation for prestige-driven programming, there appears to be tension over whether an abundance of superhero content fits the network’s traditional brand.
This disagreement could be why Peacemaker Season 2 is continuing under the Max Original banner, rather than carrying the HBO label. Although the initial strategy had called for new DCU shows to premiere directly on HBO, that direction may now be changing. If HBO remains resistant, streaming service Max might increasingly become the primary home for DCU’s expanding television universe.
Balancing Creative Ambition and Studio Demands
Amidst the shakeup, James Gunn’s wide-ranging plans for the DC Universe are under close watch. While there is still considerable excitement for what could emerge under his creative lead, it remains unclear whether the forces at HBO and the broader studio system will allow him to pursue bold storytelling and unconventional visions. As edits continue on Superman and negotiations play out over new television projects, the challenge Gunn faces in aligning his ambitions with network and studio priorities is intensifying.
With the future of the DCU resting on these upcoming decisions, fans and industry insiders alike are watching for signs of how much creative freedom Gunn will be granted—and what that means for the evolution of DC’s characters and stories.
