Taylor Sheridan on creating nonsensical Yellowstone western drama has become a defining feature of modern television, with Sheridan himself acknowledging the show‘s outlandish moments as part of its appeal. During a recent interview, Sheridan discussed how embracing the show’s unpredictability has kept audiences engaged, making Yellowstone a unique staple in the western genre.
Sheridan Embraces the Absurdity Behind Yellowstone
Yellowstone has captured the attention of millions, often leaving viewers questioning their loyalty to the Dutton family and the logic of the plot. Under the guidance of Sheridan, the show has evolved into a western powerhouse for Paramount, spawning multiple spin-offs and new projects. However, as many fans will admit, the series frequently stretches believability—such as when Kevin Costner’s character John Dutton engaged in a shootout in present-day Montana with no repercussions. Rather than seeing this as a flaw, Sheridan considers it an intentional aspect that makes the show stand out.
In a conversation with Gold Derby, Sheridan candidly addressed these elements, saying,
“With Yellowstone, which is nonsensical — there’s a great writer named Gretel Ehrlich, who calls it my horse opera because it makes no sense and it’s not trying to,”
—Taylor Sheridan, Creator
Sheridan went on to explain the show’s special relationship with its setting, focusing on the visual allure that draws in viewers.
“And yet it’s a window into a world. There’s a very sort of loving nature with the camera that attempts to sell this place as the idyllic location to raise a family. I subtracted from that in 1883, and tried to make it look slightly more foreign.”
—Taylor Sheridan, Creator
Filling a Gap in Television With a Modern Western
Sheridan recognized that television was missing a genuine western drama, and he aimed to fill that void. He described the genre’s broad appeal, highlighting why Yellowstone resonates so strongly.
“I knew there was such a thirst, that a Western done well is a universally loved genre. It captures everything American, this sense of freedom and vastness and independence. And there’s a romance to it. You get on a 1,200-pound animal, and that thing trusts you, and you trust it, and you run 40 miles an hour. It’s just so romantic and brutal and beautiful.”
—Taylor Sheridan, Creator
The series’ blend of breathtaking scenery, intense family drama, and moments that defy reality contribute to its magnetic quality. With characters like Jamie Dutton (played by Wes Bentley) and Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly) experiencing some of the show‘s most extreme plotlines—including shocking past traumas and complicated relationships—the series maintains an emotionally charged atmosphere that keeps fans returning, even when events make little logical sense.
The Allure of “Horse Opera” Storytelling
Yellowstone offers viewers an experience that veers away from everyday reality, encouraging audiences to embrace the unpredictable. Over five seasons, wild plot twists have become the norm, making it difficult even for devoted fans to choose the most outrageous moment. From Kevin Costner’s unwavering John Dutton to Sheridan’s own appearances on screen, the show thrives on turning the unexpected into entertainment.
This deliberate embrace of the nonsensical is a key reason why viewers continue to tune in, according to Sheridan. The surreal elements are, in fact, what bring people together around Yellowstone. Rather than defending the show’s eccentricities, longtime fans and new viewers alike can appreciate the unique brand of western drama that Sheridan has cultivated.
With Yellowstone and its growing roster of spin-offs and new projects, Taylor Sheridan on creating nonsensical Yellowstone western drama has not only filled a long-standing gap in television but also redefined what modern western storytelling can be. As Paramount continues to expand this universe, the show‘s blend of chaos, romance, and spectacle is likely to keep audiences hooked for seasons to come.
