James Gunn is reimagining Superman for the DCU by focusing on the hero’s vulnerability—a strategy often credited for the lasting appeal of Batman. The decision to make Superman more relatable by introducing personal and emotional weaknesses marks a significant departure in the character’s portrayal, aiming to address audiences’ past criticisms of his overpowered nature.
Superman’s Relatability Problem in Recent Media
In the past decade, Superman has been largely absent from major media releases, leading to a perception among some fans that he is too bland or uninteresting. Many attribute this to his depiction as an almost invincible character, which makes it difficult for viewers to connect with his struggles. Despite this, core fans maintain that Clark Kent’s humanity—not just his powers—is what truly defines Superman and makes him compelling.
James Gunn’s Vision: Adopting Batman’s Vulnerability
Unlike Superman, Batman has consistently captivated audiences, both in comics and on screen, by showcasing his flaws and limitations. Even without superhuman abilities, Batman’s resilience amid adversity and his struggle against notable foes have fueled his popularity. James Gunn, now steering the direction of the DCU, recognizes the value in this approach and intends to shift Superman’s image away from being invincible and toward being more human and susceptible to defeat.
Emphasizing this shift, Gunn explained his perspective in an interview with The Rolling Stone:
Honestly, in talking to people, a lot of people are like, ‘I like Batman better because he can actually be beat,’ and I get that. So we have a Superman that can be beat.
—James Gunn, Director and DCU Creative Head
Introducing David Corenswet as the new face of Superman, Gunn is determined to challenge the stereotype that Superman cannot be defeated. The aim is to craft a version of the hero whose vulnerability becomes a source of inspiration, much like audiences have witnessed with Batman’s character across films and comics.
While debates about power levels between DC’s biggest icons are popular online, Gunn’s approach counters the notion that invulnerability makes for a dull character. Instead, he intends to focus on personal growth and emotional challenges, as seen in the most celebrated Batman narratives. Here, the stakes are not just physical but deeply emotional, making the journey more meaningful for viewers.
The Influence of “The Batman” and Potential DCU Integration
The success of Robert Pattinson’s performance in “The Batman,” directed by Matt Reeves, further highlights the power of vulnerability in superhero storytelling. The film leaned into Batman’s inner struggles, making his character arc and the film’s resolution feel earned and resonant. Reeves, however, has decided to keep this saga in a separate continuity from the main DCU.
Still, James Gunn has acknowledged the possibility of merging these two portrayals if circumstances permitted:
It would be a consideration. We’d have to think about it. We’d have to think about it. It is not like we’ve never discussed it.
—James Gunn, Director and DCU Creative Head
For now, the DC Universe will develop multiple storylines in parallel, with Corenswet’s Superman and Pattinson’s Batman exploring different aspects of what makes a hero. This dual approach may enrich the overall franchise, satisfying diverse audience preferences while demonstrating how emotional depth, not just superpowers, keeps iconic characters relevant.
What This Means for Superman’s Future—and the DCU
Anticipation is high for the new direction of Superman, with the film scheduled for release in U.S. theaters on July 11, 2025. The project is positioned to be the opening feature of the new DCU, and its reception could influence the franchise’s tone moving forward. By making Superman vulnerable like Batman, James Gunn seeks to reintroduce Clark Kent as a hero whose challenges, flaws, and triumphs can inspire hope in a modern audience.
As the DCU expands with fresh interpretations and spin-offs—including more stories from “The Batman” universe—fans can expect a richer exploration of heroism that places personal stakes and emotional realism at the forefront. The result may finally bridge the gap between the world’s most famous Kryptonian and viewers hoping for a hero they can truly relate to.
