The rumor that Keanu Reeves pitched a DC Elseworlds story to James Gunn has set social media abuzz, after Gunn indicated he was recently approached by a superstar actor about a new DC project. Gunn, who leads the creative direction for DC alongside Peter Safran, has confirmed that only truly exceptional scripts stand a chance in the reimagined DC Universe, intensifying curiosity around the identity of this
“very, very, very famous movie actor.”
James Gunn’s Approach to New DC Projects
James Gunn has made it clear that the DC Universe will only move forward with films that meet his high creative standards. In a recent interview, Gunn shared that he and Peter Safran will only approve projects with screenplays they believe are exceptional, even if a major celebrity is behind the pitch. Gunn highlighted that although there is an openness to fresh takes and different stories, the quality of the writing is the top priority.
Gunn mentioned that working with celebrated filmmakers such as Matt Reeves is the rare exception due to Reeves’ artistic vision and track record. He emphasized how critical it is for proposed projects to reach a certain level of storytelling and craftsmanship before getting a green light.
Mystery Surrounds the Star Pitching an Elseworlds Tale
Gunn recounted an encounter with an unnamed, highly recognized actor who presented a potential Elseworlds narrative for DC. When asked about the likelihood of the project being made, Gunn responded that its future was wholly dependent on the quality of the script. He made it clear to the actor,
“It depends on how the screenplay comes out…If it’s a masterpiece, I’ll make it, but it has to be a masterpiece.”
—James Gunn, Filmmaker.
During their exchange, the actor displayed some uncertainty about whether the script would meet Gunn’s high expectations but remained determined to continue refining the story.
“He got all funny. He’s still working on it, though. He is still trying to do it, so we’ll see. Masterpiece might be pushing it, but it’s got to be really great.”
—James Gunn, Filmmaker.
Fan Theories Take Over the Internet
As soon as Gunn’s comments were published, speculation exploded online about which superstar could have approached him with a DC Elseworlds pitch. Among the leading theories is that Keanu Reeves, known for starring roles in John Wick and as John Constantine in DC’s previous adaptations, might be the mysterious figure, possibly envisioning his character crossing paths with Batman, Superman, or other central figures in the DCU. The phrase
“Keanu Reeves pitched DC Elseworlds story to James Gunn”
quickly gained traction among fans dissecting every clue.
Other popular guesses within the DC fan community include Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, who has played Black Adam and remains a high-profile figure keen on further DC involvement. Fans also floated names such as Bradley Cooper, Ryan Gosling, Ryan Reynolds, and even LeBron James due to his movie ambitions. Online discussion forums and Twitter feeds were filled with creative theories and humorous suggestions, reflecting the high level of anticipation and excitement in the DC fandom.
NICHOLAS CAGE AS THE QUESTION LETS GOOOOOO!!! https://t.co/BlbJmaRqKFJune 19, 2025
Some eagle-eyed fans expanded the list of possible candidates to include actors like Nicholas Cage, with references to his passion for comic book roles and unique storytelling styles.
it’s almost certainly ryan reynolds but i’m trying to think of the funniest options of who it Could be and i have 31. vin diesel2. tom cruise3. dwayne johnson https://t.co/bpIzRTW6AsJune 19, 2025
Others speculated about Ryan Reynolds, known for his performances in various superhero roles, while jokingly considering big names like Vin Diesel, Tom Cruise, and Dwayne Johnson as contenders for the secret pitch.
Spotlight on Other DC Projects and Potential Talent
Discussion also turned to Michael B. Jordan, who announced plans in 2021 to develop a Black Superman series about Val-Zod for HBO Max. Despite not yet having scripted this particular project, Jordan’s experience as a director, such as with his successful work on Creed 3 and the upcoming reboot of The Thomas Crown Affair, keeps his name in play as both an actor and creative force.
Meanwhile, James Gunn’s efforts to maintain integrity in the DCU continue to be closely watched. He has previously chosen to halt production even on fully prepared DC movies if the screenplays did not meet his standards, demonstrating a serious commitment to quality over expediency. The issue of Batman’s role remains a significant challenge for Gunn, with ongoing rumors about the possibility of Robert Pattinson providing new solutions.
What This Means for DC and Its Fans
The revelation that a global superstar like Keanu Reeves may have pitched an Elseworlds storyline to James Gunn only adds to the drama and anticipation surrounding the new DCU. The ongoing public speculation underscores both the intensity of fan engagement and the heightened expectations for DC films going forward. As Gunn remains open to extraordinary pitches while insisting that only outstanding scripts move forward, the question is not just who is behind the mystery project, but whether it will ever make its way to the big screen. For now, audiences remain on the edge of their seats, awaiting more official news from Gunn, Peter Safran, and the ever-expanding roster of Hollywood talent eager to shape the next chapter of DC storytelling.
