Henry Cavill‘s Night Hunter comeback on Paramount Plus has taken the world by storm, as the movie—which was once considered his biggest flop—has soared into the streaming service’s Top 10 in 2025. The film‘s unexpected resurgence spotlights Cavill, famed for roles like Superman and Geralt of Rivia, reclaiming attention for a project many wrote off, proving that Hollywood careers can be unpredictable and full of second chances.
From Flop to Streaming Success: The Journey of Night Hunter
Since making waves in Hollywood with his breakthrough in The Tudors, Henry Cavill has remained a sought-after name, recognized for his performances in high-profile films such as Man of Steel, where he embodied Superman, and in The Witcher as Geralt of Rivia. Despite setbacks in recent years, including stepping away from major roles like Superman in James Gunn’s DCEU and leaving The Witcher series, Cavill’s dedicated fan base has not waivered. The current buzz around Night Hunter, now trending in the Top 10 on Paramount Plus, reinforces his enduring popularity.
Night Hunter, also known as Nomis and released in 2018, was directed by David Raymond and initially made little impact in theaters—grossing only about $919,000 worldwide according to box office trackers, and suffering from critical disappointment with just a 14% Rotten Tomatoes score and an IMDb rating of 5.9/10. Many critics pointed to its uneven pacing and a plot that struggled to deliver on its intriguing premise, centering on a serial killer who continues to commit crimes from behind bars. Nonetheless, Cavill took on the role of Detective Walter Marshall, working alongside Alexandra Daddario’s character, Rachel Chase, as they pursue justice for the killer’s victims.
The film‘s cast showcased notable talents, including Ben Kingsley, Stanley Tucci, Brendan Fletcher, Minka Kelly, Nathan Fillion, Tyler Hoechlin, and Alexandra Daddario. Despite the strong ensemble, Night Hunter’s initial performance was underwhelming and marked a rare low in Cavill’s otherwise impressive career.
Now, the movie’s renaissance on Paramount Plus signals a remarkable shift. According to recent data from FlixPatrol, Night Hunter is seeing revived popularity, particularly ranking between 7th and 10th among streaming titles in countries from Argentina to Mexico. This newfound global audience is breathing new life into a film once overlooked both commercially and critically.
Alexandra Daddario Reflects on Working with Cavill and Hoechlin
While Night Hunter’s underwhelming box office showing was a disappointment for the entire cast and crew, Alexandra Daddario found notable joy in the experience. The actress, widely recognized for her role in San Andreas, spoke enthusiastically about her time on set, emphasizing the privilege of working alongside not only Henry Cavill but also Tyler Hoechlin, who is known for portraying Superman in The CW’s Superman & Lois. Daddario’s admiration reveals the camaraderie among the cast members and highlights the collaborative spirit behind Night Hunter’s production.
“They’re very, very wonderful actors, wonderful actors to work with, and really considerate co-stars. I’m just lucky. I feel really lucky in these two films to have worked with the kinds of people with whom I had the opportunity to work. As I go through my career and I work more and more, it’s more and more important to me to work with people that are passionate and kind and care about what they’re doing, and to work with good people. And they’re both absolutely wonderful.”
—Alexandra Daddario, Actress
Daddario also reminisced about the vibrant and kind atmosphere on set, sharing her appreciation for the opportunity to collaborate with esteemed actors like Cavill and Hoechlin. This sentiment underscores the professional and passionate environment maintained by the film’s cast—a factor that may contribute to the growing fan interest in revisiting Night Hunter on streaming platforms such as Paramount Plus and Prime Video in the USA.
The Ripple Effect of Night Hunter’s Unexpected Revival
The resurgence of Night Hunter on Paramount Plus is a testament to the unpredictable nature of film reception in the digital era. For Henry Cavill, it’s a vivid reminder of both the challenges and opportunities that define a Hollywood career. As the film enjoys a revival, showcasing performances from notable figures such as Ben Kingsley, Stanley Tucci, Nathan Fillion, Brendan Fletcher, and Minka Kelly, it also opens doors for curious new viewers and long-time fans alike. The streaming comeback could influence future discussions around career-defining moments, second acts for previously dismissed projects, and the role of platforms like Paramount Plus in renewing cultural interest in hidden gems.
As Night Hunter claims its position among this year’s streaming surprises, the spotlight returns to Henry Cavill’s diverse filmography, Alexandra Daddario’s reflections on creative partnerships, and the collaborative achievements of the cast and crew. This revival may inspire a reassessment of projects that once struggled in the box office, proving that cinematic history is always open to rewriting.
