Pedro Pascal has publicly addressed the Pedro Pascal Fantastic Four casting backlash, drawing parallels to earlier skepticism he faced when joining “The Last of Us.” In a recent interview, Pascal acknowledged the divided public response to his selection as Reed Richards, expressing a determination to once again overturn negative expectations, just as he did before.
Reaction to Pedro Pascal’s Casting as Reed Richards
Since the announcement of Pedro Pascal as Marvel’s new Reed Richards, known as Mister Fantastic, fan reactions have been immediate and polarized. The debate centers around whether Pascal physically embodies the iconic stretchy genius character, with some fixating on his age or even his facial hair. Despite his acclaimed roles as Oberyn Martell in “Game of Thrones” and as the masked titular figure in “The Mandalorian,” doubts persist among certain viewers, skeptics, and Marvel fans, who are never shy about voicing their strong opinions.
Addressing the intense scrutiny, Pascal openly discussed the negativity and concerns in a candid interview.
“I’m getting an inkling of excitement because it seems to reflect what our common goal was, and what we want to share, which is all of our f***ing hearts on a platter within this genre. You just never know if people are going to be disgusted by your heart or not. I’m more aware of disgruntlement around my casting than anything I’ve ever done. He’s too old. He’s not right. He needs to shave.”
—Pedro Pascal, Interview with Vanity Fair
He revealed that he is untouched by the negativity and, in some ways, invigorated by the chance to prove doubters and naysayers wrong once again. The Marvel Cinematic Universe’s decision to select him signals their confidence, a sentiment underscored by reports suggesting the studio is already planning a sequel to “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” ahead of the film’s official release. This willingness to move forward is a bold commitment from Marvel and points to strong support within the studio for Pascal and the new lineup.
Echoes of Past Criticism from “The Last of Us”
This is not the first time Pascal has been at the center of casting controversy. When HBO introduced him as Joel in “The Last of Us,” many fans of the original video game expressed disappointment and outrage, arguing that Pascal did not resemble Joel’s grizzled, animated version. Some went so far as to question specifics like his beard and ruggedness. Meanwhile, others in the fanbase campaigned online for Game of Thrones’ Nikolaj Coster-Waldau or even actor Hugh Jackman to be given the role, believing their looks better suited the character’s energy.
Once the show debuted, critics and viewers alike recognized Pascal’s remarkable portrayal of Joel as a haunted protector, ultimately silencing the initial complaints. In fact, acclaim for his performance grew so widespread that even the most ardent skeptics and haters were converted. This turnaround highlights how presence, emotional range, and performance often outweigh superficial matters like physical resemblance, a point frequently overlooked during online debates about casting in major franchise projects.
The issue of judging actors on their appearance remains persistent in entertainment culture. For instance, Bella Ramsey, celebrated as fierce Lyanna Mormont in “Game of Thrones,” faced ongoing backlash after being chosen as Ellie in “The Last of Us,” even though her acting ability has earned her considerable praise. The conversation around who fits a role continues to spark intense reactions, with the distinction between skeptics and true believers in a performer’s range dividing commentators.
Marvel’s High-Stakes Confidence and What Lies Ahead
The decision by Marvel Studios to begin planning a follow-up to “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” before the movie’s arrival in theaters further demonstrates their faith in the assembled cast, including Pascal as Reed Richards. This is a significant endorsement, reflecting the studio’s belief that viewers, once exposed to his performance, will embrace his interpretation and move beyond their initial doubts. The pattern seen with “The Last of Us” gives reason to expect that, as before, those skeptical of Pascal’s casting might ultimately be won over by his dedication and skill.
The pressure remains high, as expectations for the long-awaited “Fantastic Four” reboot are immense, given the franchise’s legacy in comic and cinematic history. Marvel, under global scrutiny, is betting on both the appeal and acting prowess of Pascal to deliver on fans’ hopes and re-shape their perceptions, turning initial backlash into support.
Audiences will soon be able to judge for themselves: “The Last of Us” is streaming on HBO Max, and Marvel’s “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” is scheduled to hit theaters in the USA on July 25, 2025. Both franchises highlight not just the challenge Pascal faces with vocal doubters, but also his established reputation for turning skepticism into enthusiasm through commanding performances.
