Rachel Brosnahan romantic movie love story fans can now revisit the indie film
“I’m Obsessed With You: But You’ve Got to Leave Me Alone,”
where Rachel Brosnahan and Jason Ralph first met during filming in 2013, which ultimately led to their real-life romance. The film, which recently returned to Amazon Prime Video, was the unlikely backdrop for the beginning of the couple’s relationship, despite previous assumptions about where their story began.
The Unlikely Beginning of Rachel Brosnahan and Jason Ralph’s Relationship
Rachel Brosnahan and Jason Ralph’s story did not begin on the set of the Manhattan TV series as many believed, but during the making of the little-known indie movie “I’m Obsessed With You.” On-set in 2013, a small production team, including Brosnahan, Ralph, and other cast members, lived together in a dorm while filming at Dartmouth College, as well as in New York City and the Hamptons. Although Brosnahan and Ralph were not cast as a pair in the movie, the unique atmosphere fostered a close-knit camaraderie.
Brosnahan later disclosed that their connection did not turn romantic until filming was complete, despite Ralph’s interest during production. She explained her initial reservations about starting a relationship at work, humorously recounting:
It was a hard no for me. Stay away, stay away. Okay, fine.
—Rachel Brosnahan, Actor
Once the project ended, the two began dating and have remained together since 2013. By 2018, rumors spread that Brosnahan and Ralph had married secretly; however, Brosnahan later clarified during an appearance at the 2019 SAG Awards that they had indeed been married for some time, though the timeline remains private. Jason Ralph, known for his role as Quentin Coldwater in “The Magicians,” and Brosnahan maintained discretion surrounding their relationship for years.
The Film’s Quiet Release and Rediscovery
Although “I’m Obsessed With You” became the start of Brosnahan and Ralph’s romance, the movie itself largely evaded widespread attention. Adapted from the off-Broadway play “IMPROVed” by Dartmouth alum Genevieve Adams, the script found its way to the screen through a successful Kickstarter campaign. The cast included Rachel Brosnahan, Jason Ralph, Manish Dayal of “The Resident,” Thomas McDonell, and Adams herself. The indie film premiered at the Sonoma International Film Festival before launching through video-on-demand services, and those few who watched it on these platforms gave it a modest 67% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
By 2021, “I’m Obsessed With You” had disappeared from streaming platforms entirely. The film gained renewed interest in April 2025 when a listener of Alex Goldman’s “Hyperfixed” podcast inquired about its disappearance. Goldman’s investigation led him to Adams, who admitted she removed the movie from streaming, believing there was little demand for it. The resulting podcast episode brought attention to the film, encouraging Adams to restore it to Amazon Prime Video for US audiences. Notably, this project represented Brosnahan’s earliest leading film role, even before her breakout successes.
Why Brosnahan and Ralph Guarded Their Private Life
Contrary to reports suggesting Rachel Brosnahan deliberately hid her marriage, she clarified that privacy motivated her choice to keep her personal life out of the spotlight. She addressed the double standard in how she and her husband, both prominent television leads, were treated by the media. At the 2019 SAG Awards, Brosnahan explained:
Jason and I also noticed early on that, while we are both the leads of successful television series, he has almost never been asked about our relationship while I have been asked on almost every red carpet I have walked in the last two years. We both find this double standard problematic and frustrating and opted to redirect those conversations to our work.
—Rachel Brosnahan, Actor
The couple’s approach to privacy was shaped by persistent questions Brosnahan faced regarding their marriage, prompting them to prioritize their work rather than their relationship status. That night at the SAG Awards, after her win for “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,” Brosnahan and Ralph celebrated together. She later publicly thanked Ralph during her Golden Globe acceptance speech, highlighting the important role he played in her career:
Jason, I love you. I wouldn’t be here at all without you. Thank you
—Rachel Brosnahan, Actor
Recent Collaborations and Continued Careers
In 2021, Jason Ralph joined the cast of Brosnahan’s show, portraying the character Mike Carr. Ralph previously played key roles, such as Quentin Coldwater in “The Magicians,” a regular in “Younger” (2018), and he appeared in “Three Women,” a series on Starz in 2024. Brosnahan’s own career flourished with multiple awards, including the SAG and Golden Globe for “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.”
“I’m Obsessed With You: But You’ve Got to Leave Me Alone”
is now streaming on Prime Video, allowing audiences to see the film that quietly set the stage for Rachel Brosnahan romantic movie love story in real life. The film is now available for new viewers and devoted fans alike to explore the origins of this celebrated couple’s connection.
The re-release not only grants broader access to a once-forgotten indie film, but also highlights how unexpected collaborations and quiet beginnings can spark relationships and careers that flourish for years. As Brosnahan and Ralph continue their individual and joint ventures, their story remains an example of how life on and off screen can merge in surprising ways.
