David Corenswet has expressed interest in portraying a darker, R-rated version of Superman, a concept that aligns well with a classic DC Comics story James Gunn could adapt to expand the DC Universe (DCU). This vision could bring a more intense and mature take on the Man of Steel while complementing upcoming projects within the DCU framework.
The Appeal of an R-Rated Superman for David Corenswet
Before the release of the new Superman film starring David Corenswet, there have already been discussions about exploring a grittier, more serious interpretation of the iconic superhero. In an interview with Nerdist, Corenswet shared his enthusiasm for a Superman project that captures a mood similar to the television series True Detective, emphasizing tone over graphic violence.
“I would love to see this Superman in an R-rated project… in a thing like Lanterns where it’s that True Detective’ feel.”
—David Corenswet, actor
He acknowledged the current portrayal as relatively light and family-friendly but believes there is potential for flexibility within the character’s depiction.
“In spite of how bright and playful this version is, I think there’s room to be flexible.”
—David Corenswet, actor
This openness suggests a path for James Gunn’s DCU to explore Superman’s character with depth and darkness, further enriching the narrative possibilities.
James Gunn’s Ideal Story for a Mature Superman Adaptation
A fitting source for this R-rated Superman approach is the 2001 comic written by Joe Kelly, titled What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, & the American Way?. The story introduces a controversial group called The Elite, a team of ruthless heroes who exercise lethal force against enemies, gaining notable public support. Their morally ambiguous methods sharply contrast with Superman’s traditional values.
The narrative escalates when Superman confronts The Elite after they kill terrorists without hesitation. The confrontation moves to Io, a moon orbiting Jupiter, where a fierce battle ensues. The Elite land heavy blows on Superman, but ultimately, an unseen Superman attacks and seemingly kills the team members, revealing afterward that they survived and were imprisoned.
This story arc showcases Superman defending his unwavering belief in justice and morality, emphasizing that true heroism goes beyond lethal efficiency. The comic’s mature themes and complex ethical questions make it a strong candidate for adaptation in a more adult-oriented film within the DCU.
Given James Gunn’s interest in bringing complexity to superhero tales and his role in shaping the DCU’s future, this comic could provide the perfect foundation for the R-rated Superman role David Corenswet envisions.
Connecting This Storyline With the DCU’s Upcoming The Authority Project
James Gunn recently confirmed a new DCU project centered on The Authority, a group of superheroes known for their aggressive methods and disregard for political or legal constraints. This team often engages in covert missions, including revolutions and coups, acting with their own sense of justice rather than following established rules.
The Authority’s morally ambiguous actions mirror the approach taken by The Elite in the 2001 comic. Because both teams challenge traditional hero ethics, incorporating the Superman vs. The Elite storyline could naturally lead into or intersect with The Authority plotline, creating a cohesive narrative thread throughout the DCU.
This alignment offers an opportunity for Corenswet’s Superman to face darker challenges and question his ideals in a world where heroes operate in shades of gray. Such thematic resonance would deepen the DCU’s storytelling and satisfy fans looking for a more intense and serious tone in its superhero films.
By adapting this story, James Gunn can simultaneously fulfill Corenswet’s hopes for a more mature Superman and set the stage for The Authority’s introduction, making the universe richer and more interconnected.
Looking Ahead: What This Means for the DC Universe
The planned theatrical release of Superman on July 11, 2025, marks a significant step toward bringing this version of the character to audiences worldwide. While the current iteration may be lighter, the groundwork for a darker, R-rated adaptation is gaining momentum, fueled by Corenswet’s vision and supported by James Gunn’s creative direction.
Fans and followers of the DCU eagerly anticipate how these elements will unfold, with many hoping that the powerful moral questions and dramatic conflicts in What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice, & the American Way? will finally be realized on the big screen.
This development could redefine Superman’s role within the DC Universe, presenting a character who grapples with modern complexities and challenges the audience to reconsider the true meaning of heroism.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Does James Gunn believe in God?
A. Gunn grew up in a Catholic household and has shared that prayer still matters a lot to him. However, he also described himself as “in some ways, anti-religion.”
Q. Why is James Gunn leaving Marvel?
A. When Gunn was made co-CEO of DC Studios, he committed solely to that company, which means he won’t work on Marvel Studios projects anymore. Gunn, known for writing and directing the Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy, developed strong friendships with its cast members.
