Why Florence Pugh’s Most Underrated Movie, Fighting with My Family, Deserves More Love

Florence Pugh has become one of Hollywood’s most prominent new talents, earning acclaim for roles in blockbusters like Midsommar and Dune: Part Two. Yet, her film Fighting with My Family remains a hidden gem that underscores her incredible range. Released several years ago, this movie showcases Pugh’s ability to carry a compelling story with authenticity, making it one of her most underrated performances despite strong critical and audience ratings.

The Real Story Behind the Film’s Narrative

Fighting with My Family tells the true story of Saraya Bevis, played by Florence Pugh, who grows up in a wrestling family before earning a chance to try out for WWE in the United States. The film explores Saraya’s demanding training, emotional struggles, and moments of doubt as she pursues her dream. Meanwhile, her brother Zak, portrayed by Jack Lowden, also strives for wrestling success but faces setbacks that shape their individual journeys in contrasting ways. What distinguishes the movie is its focus on raw, realistic characters who grapple with genuine flaws, steering clear of clichés.

Florence Pugh’s Subtle Yet Powerful Portrayal

Pugh delivers a nuanced performance that avoids melodrama, instead relying on quiet presence and expressive subtleties. She captures Saraya’s awkwardness and insecurity amidst a world of put-together athletes with striking realism. Rather than a typical triumphant underdog story, the film highlights the emotional toll of fitting in where acceptance is scarce. The character’s internal conflict is palpable through moments of anger, frustration, and vulnerability, making her arc relatable and grounded in everyday struggles.

Florence Pugh
Image of: Florence Pugh

Supporting Cast That Bolsters the Story’s Depth

The supporting actors contribute significantly to the film’s emotional texture. Vince Vaughn’s portrayal of the wrestling coach veers away from the conventional supportive mentor archetype; he is blunt and often harsh, reinforcing the tough environment Saraya must navigate. Jack Lowden brings sincerity and frustration to Zak’s character, providing a counterbalance to Saraya’s narrative. The family, played by Nick Frost and Lena Headey, offers warmth and humor without descending into caricature, adding complexity to the familial dynamics and relief to the story’s intense moments.

Direction That Prioritizes Emotion Over Spectacle

The movie’s straightforward direction focuses tightly on performances and emotional resonance instead of flashy fight sequences. The wrestling scenes are well-executed but never overshadow the characters’ personal growth and emotional stakes. The final ring scenes carry significant tension and weight, reflecting all Saraya’s sacrifices and struggles rather than merely showcasing athletic prowess. This approach invites comparisons to classic sports dramas like Rocky, not for grandeur, but for its portrayal of a deeply personal journey earned through persistence.

Why the Film Has Been Overlooked Despite Its Merits

Despite winning solid approval from critics and audiences alike, Fighting with My Family has not received the attention it merits within Florence Pugh’s diverse filmography. Often overshadowed by the buzz of prestige titles like Midsommar, Little Women, or major franchise films including those from Marvel, this film exists in a less glamorous middle ground that can easily be missed. Yet, it clearly demonstrated early on Pugh’s capacity to lead a movie with captivating charm, timing, and emotional depth.

The Film’s Lasting Significance in Florence Pugh’s Career

As Florence Pugh establishes herself as a premier actress of her generation, it is important to recognize the contributions of Fighting with My Family to her rise. The film reveals a side of her talent that goes beyond blockbuster spectacle or intense dramatic roles: an actress who deeply understands character development and subtlety. By portraying a realistic, flawed, yet determined young woman, Pugh delivers a performance that is both grounded and inspiring. This makes Fighting with My Family arguably her most underrated movie, deserving renewed appreciation and viewership.

For those interested in experiencing this compelling story, Fighting with My Family is currently available to stream on Prime Video.

Our Reader’s Queries

Q. What is Florence Pugh’s illness?

A. As a child, she had tracheomalacia, which is a condition affecting the windpipe and causing breathing issues. This resulted in her often being hospitalized.

Q. Why does Florence Pugh have short hair?

A. The 28-year-old actress, Florence Pugh, shared why she chose to cut her hair for her next movie, We Live in Time. In this romantic drama, Pugh acts alongside Andrew Garfield, portraying Almut, a chef battling stage 3 ovarian cancer. “Shaving it was really strange,” she mentioned in an interview.

Q. What illness does Florence Pugh have?

A. Pugh suffers from both polycystic ovary syndrome and endometriosis.

Q. Why is Florence Pugh’s voice so deep?

A. Here’s why Oscar nominee Florence Pugh speaks with a raspy voice. She explained to Vogue that she has tracheomalacia. This condition causes the trachea to narrow or collapse during breathing. According to Boston Children’s Hospital, it can lead to noisy breathing, frequent bronchitis, a loud cough, and respiratory infections.