Edi Gathegi recently revealed the challenging decision he faced when offered the role of Mr. Terrific in the new Superman film, which led him to leave a high-profile project starring Robert De Niro. This choice occurred during the early 2020s amid production delays from industry strikes, pushing Gathegi to consider the long-term impact on his career before joining the DC Universe (DCU).
While David Corenswet took the lead role as Superman in James Gunn’s film, Gathegi’s performance as Mr. Terrific has drawn significant praise from audiences and critics alike. However, securing this role meant turning down a part in the political thriller Netflix mini-series Zero Day, featuring Robert De Niro and directed by Lesli Linka Glatter—a project Gathegi describes as a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
“I was a bit bummed because working with De Niro was definitely a bucket-list thing, and I know and love the director, Lesli Linka Glatter.”
—Edi Gathegi, Actor
Despite the personal regret tied to missing out on working with De Niro, Gathegi said the decision was rooted in his vision for growth. Leaving Zero Day was not easy, but he recognized the potential for long-term success that came with being part of a revitalized and expanding superhero franchise.
How Leaving ‘Zero Day’ Accelerated Gathegi’s Rise in Hollywood
For Edi Gathegi, career decisions have significantly shaped his journey in entertainment. Born to Kenyan and American heritage, Gathegi’s path now prominently showcases his role as Mr. Terrific, a testament to calculated risks taken during uncertain times. At the moment when Zero Day’s production stalled due to the ongoing SAG-AFTRA strikes, the Superman opportunity emerged as a more viable and lasting route.

Gathegi’s choice to commit to DC Studios aligns with his desire to be part of a franchise with enduring potential. In interviews, he emphasized that the decision was strategic, focusing on the sustainability of the project rather than just the prestige of working alongside highly regarded figures like De Niro.
Since the film’s release, Gathegi’s portrayal has resonated strongly with cinephiles, highlighting not only his talent but also the importance of navigating career moves with foresight in the competitive industry.
From ‘X-Men: First Class’ to the DC Universe: A Fresh Chapter
Audiences who have followed Gathegi’s work might recall his role as Darwin in the 2011 film X-Men: First Class. Although Darwin was initially introduced as a promising character, his early exit in the film meant that Gathegi’s impact on the franchise was limited. This previous experience contributed to his cautious approach toward franchise projects and the significance he placed on picking roles with long-term value.
With Mr. Terrific, Gathegi now enjoys a fresh narrative arc within the DCU. Though his role is a supporting one, the positive reception suggests that the filmmakers may have future plans to further develop his character. This new opportunity not only showcases his acting range but also represents a pivotal point in his career trajectory.
As Warner Bros. and DC Studios continue to expand their cinematic universe, Gathegi’s involvement could prove critical, potentially elevating his standing among major franchise stars.
The Broader Impact of Gathegi’s Role in ‘Superman’
Gathegi’s decision to step away from a star-studded project to embrace a key part in Superman reflects the complex choices actors face in balancing prestige with career sustainability. His move carries significance beyond his personal story, illustrating broader trends within Hollywood where actors weigh the longevity of franchise roles against standalone projects.
Now that Superman is screening worldwide, Gathegi’s success hints at a promising future for his character and expands the diversity and depth of the DCU cast. His choice underscores the strategic considerations necessary for actors aiming to build lasting legacies in a competitive market.
Fans and critics will be watching closely to see how Mr. Terrific’s role evolves in upcoming installments, as well as how Gathegi’s career continues to develop after this pivotal moment.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Robert De Niro Italian or Albanian?
A. Robert De Niro’s grandfather on his father’s side was Italian. His other heritage includes Irish, English, Dutch, German, and French roots. He learned acting at the Stella Adler Conservatory and the American Workshop.
Q. Why did Jennifer Lawrence ask Robert De Niro to leave her wedding?
A. Jennifer Lawrence did not enjoy her wedding rehearsal dinner. She decided to ask Robert De Niro to leave. During a red carpet interview with E! News on January 7, Lawrence described being a bride as very stressful.
Q. How many times has Robert De Niro been married and how many kids does he have?
A. Robert De Niro has been married two times and is a father to seven kids. You can view pictures of his ex-spouses and family here.
Q. Can Robert De Niro speak Italian?
A. Robert De Niro has always taken pride in his Italian heritage. In fact, his great-grandparents came from Molise. His skill in speaking the Sicilian dialect in “The Godfather II” helped him earn an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor.
