James Gunn’s latest Superman movie recently premiered, drawing widespread praise for its heartfelt portrayal of the iconic superhero. Unlike previous depictions that leaned toward darker, more cynical interpretations—such as those seen in Zack Snyder’s DCEU films or the Injustice franchise—Gunn’s version highlights a more optimistic and sincere take. In a recent interview, Gunn, along with lead actor David Corenswet and co-stars Rachel Brosnahan and Nicholas Hoult, addressed one of the most debated aspects of Superman’s character: his reluctance to kill.
The discussion focused on why Superman refrains from taking lives, a topic often compared to similar debates around Batman and other heroes. David Corenswet provided insight, stating,
I think the main reason is that he sees the good in just about everybody, maybe to a fault. He even sees the good in those trying to do him harm.
—David Corenswet, Actor
However, James Gunn added a nuanced layer to this understanding by emphasizing Superman’s belief in a fundamental right to life while admitting that the hero is not an absolute pacifist. He said,
I believe that he believes in a basic right to life. I think that it’s just not in him. But I’m also not a purist in that respect. I think that if, for instance, he had to kill to protect somebody’s life, he would probably do that. Even though it’d be hard for him.
—James Gunn, Writer and Director
Alignment with Zack Snyder’s Interpretation of Superman’s Tough Decisions
This perspective surprisingly aligns closely with the portrayal of Superman in Zack Snyder’s 2013 film, Man of Steel, where the character faces a critical moment in which he kills General Zod to save innocent lives. Snyder’s depiction sparked controversy upon release, with some fans questioning whether Superman would realistically make such a choice. Gunn’s comments suggest that this moral complexity remains relevant to the character, regardless of the differing tonal approaches between directors.
While some fans who strongly favor Snyder’s version had initially opposed Gunn’s take and his stewardship of DC Studios, it appears that Gunn shares a similar core philosophy regarding Superman’s moral limits. The new film showcases Superman striving to preserve as many lives as possible, highlighting his hopefulness in contrast to the darker, more violent outcomes of past superhero films. This approach represents a fresh and potentially more hopeful shift for the character in contemporary superhero cinema.
Whether or not future installments will compel Gunn’s Superman to face circumstances that force him into grave decisions, such as taking a life, remains to be seen. Nonetheless, the openness in Gunn’s philosophy allows for complex character development that does not confine the Man of Steel to rigid moral frameworks.
James Gunn’s Interpretation Encourages Creative Freedom in Storytelling
Gunn’s refusal to identify as a “purist” regarding Superman’s unwillingness to kill challenges online narratives that depict his version of the character as lacking seriousness or gravitas. Instead, it indicates his willingness to explore difficult choices when storytelling demands it. This flexibility contrasts with some fans’ expectations but promises a layered and dynamic portrayal of Superman that embraces both hope and the harsh realities of heroic responsibility.
The new Superman film, written and directed by James Gunn, marks the first chapter in Warner Bros.’ rebooted DC Universe following Henry Cavill’s exit from the role. David Corenswet takes on the role of Clark Kent / Superman / Kal-El, joined by Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane and Nicholas Hoult portraying Lex Luthor. Gunn’s version honors Superman as
“the embodiment of truth, justice and the American way,”
grounding the character in his classic roots while offering fresh narrative possibilities for the future.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Why is James Gunn leaving Marvel?
A. In 2018, Marvel let go of James Gunn because some of his old, offensive tweets came back into the spotlight. These tweets included jokes about serious topics like pedophilia, rape, and abuse, which upset the public.
Q. What is James Gunn’s religion?
A. Ozu inspired the updated, CGI version of Krypto the Superdog in James Gunn’s 2025 Superman adaptation. Gunn grew up in a Catholic family and has shared that prayer is still significant to him. However, he has also expressed being somewhat opposed to organized religion.
Q. What religion is James Gunn?
A. Gunn grew up in a Catholic household and still finds prayer important in his life. However, he sometimes considers himself “against religion” in certain ways.
