The new Superman film features a brief but memorable scene in which the hero pauses during a chaotic battle to rescue a squirrel in danger. Writer, director, and DC Universe chief James Gunn revealed that this moment, though simple, sparked heated debate among test audiences and even some members of his production team. Despite the pushback, Gunn chose to keep the sequence, emphasizing its importance to the character’s nature and the film’s message.
Audience Criticism Highlights Ethical Dilemmas in the Scene
Some viewers found the squirrel-saving moment jarring, questioning why Superman would halt his fight with a city-threatening monster to save a small animal. Concerns arose over the practical implications: if Superman values one squirrel’s life, why not every tiny creature affected during the destruction? Critics wondered if the scene raised unwanted questions about selective heroism or hinted at moral contradictions in Superman’s actions. The fact that the character later resorts to lethal measures against human foes deepened the debate about his ethical framework.
James Gunn’s Explanation for Preserving the Scene
In an interview with Rolling Stone, Gunn acknowledged the controversy, calling the squirrel rescue one of the most hotly discussed moments in the movie. He explained that after initially removing it, the scene was reinstated because it served a narrative and geographic purpose, showing Superman transporting the squirrel to safety as he flies through the city. Gunn resisted the objections from his team, standing by his decision to retain the gesture of saving even the smallest life.
“It was probably the second- or third-most hotly debated moment in the movie,” —James Gunn, Writer/Director
“They’re like, ‘Why the f*** is he saving a squirrel? Why is he taking time out, saving a squirrel?’ There was a cut where I cut it out and I’m like, ‘I really miss the squirrel. He’s gotta save the squirrel.’ In addition, there were also some geographic problems with where he ended up if I didn’t have him fly over with the squirrel. So I put the squirrel back in despite the protestations of some of my people on my crew.” —James Gunn, Writer/Director
The Moment Reflects a Broader Message About Compassion
The squirrel rescue serves as a reminder that Superman’s heroism extends beyond grand battles and saving humanity—it also includes caring for the smallest and most vulnerable creatures. Gunn’s portrayal of Superman highlights his empathy and willingness to protect every form of life, no matter how insignificant it may seem. The hero’s motivation in the film often stems from personal attachments and a desire to stand up for the oppressed, illustrated by his efforts to protect the fictional, war-torn country of Jarhanpur and its struggling residents.
Superman’s Moral Complexity Through Simple Acts
Though Superman’s character can sometimes be seen as straightforward, Gunn uses moments like the squirrel-saving scene to deepen his complexity. Unlike Batman’s internal struggles and darker persona, Superman faces conflict with a world that frequently undervalues life. This clash between an idealistic hero and harsh realities forms the emotional core of the film. The small act of kindness towards the squirrel symbolizes Superman’s broader commitment to defending all life, reflecting why the character remains relevant and compelling across decades of storytelling.
Implications of the Squirrel Scene for Superman’s Characterization
Keeping the squirrel scene reinforces the idea that Superman’s heroism is inclusive and personal. It shows that he is not just a powerful figure battling cosmic threats but also a protector of the everyday and overlooked. The moment provokes viewers to consider what true compassion means and challenges them to see heroism in acts big and small. For a character often burdened by expectations and criticism, this scene embodies a quieter, more relatable form of strength.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Does James Gunn believe in God?
A. Gunn grew up in a Catholic household and still finds prayer to be significant. However, he has expressed being somewhat against organized religion.
Q. Is James Gunn no longer with Marvel?
A. Before moving to DC Studios as co-CEO in 2022, Gunn collaborated with Marvel Studios on the Guardians of the Galaxy movies. After being let go by Marvel, he directed The Suicide Squad (2021) for DC. Eventually, he was rehired by Marvel for Guardians of the Galaxy 3.
Q. What is James Gunn’s religion?
A. In Gunn’s 2025 version of Superman, the redesigned, CGI Krypto the Superdog was inspired by Ozu. Gunn grew up in a Catholic family and still values prayer. However, he has also expressed some anti-religion views.
