Ari Aster, known for directing intense horror films like Hereditary and Midsommar, was once approached to direct Sony’s Marvel spinoff Morbius. The filmmaker revealed in a Semafor Media podcast that he was asked to helm the project but ultimately declined, sparking curiosity about how his distinct style might have reshaped the film.
Morbius’ Struggles and Disappointing Reception
Morbius, starring Jared Leto as a living vampire, was a significant box office failure, grossing only $167.5 million worldwide and receiving a 15% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite a second theatrical run fueled by viral memes, it earned just an additional $280,000. The film’s poor reception left fans and critics questioning what could have been done differently.
Imagining a Darker Take on Morbius by Aster
Given Ari Aster’s signature slow-burn, unsettling approach, his version of Morbius might have merged his mastery of existential dread with gothic vampire horror. Fans have speculated that his involvement could have elevated the film into a haunting and compelling experience, contrasting dramatically with the final product, which many found underwhelming.
Insights from Cast on Industry Pressures
Jared Harris, who appeared in Morbius, acknowledged the financial motivations behind some actors’ project choices:
I have got a mortgage to pay, you know. Sometimes you say yes to things because you need to make money.
—Jared Harris
Unlike many involved, Aster seemed less influenced by such pressures, choosing instead to focus on creating unique, auteur-driven works that reflect his distinct vision.
Ari Aster’s Continued Path and Future Projects
Instead of joining the Marvel universe through Morbius, Ari Aster has kept developing his signature style. His latest film, Eddington, features a high-profile cast including Joaquin Phoenix, Pedro Pascal, Emma Stone, and Austin Butler, demonstrating his ongoing commitment to compelling, character-driven cinema.
The Lasting Question of What Might Have Been
Though Ari Aster passed on Marvel’s Morbius, the idea of a chilling, folk-horror-infused vampire story within the Marvel spinoff framework remains a tantalizing “what if.” While the actual Morbius struggled to find its footing, imagining Aster’s influence leaves fans restless, pondering how differently the film could have turned out under his direction.
