Dean Cain, best known for playing Superman in the 1993 series Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman, has openly criticized James Gunn’s recent Superman film within the DC Universe (DCU). Cain expressed his frustrations in a Variety interview, focusing on what he sees as questionable creative decisions involving Superman’s vulnerability in combat and the depiction of his adoptive parents, Jonathan and Martha Kent.
Cain highlighted his concerns about how often Superman is saved during the movie, questioning the choice behind making the iconic hero repeatedly reliant on others. Regarding the Kents, he remarked critically on their characterization, suggesting it felt out of character for such pivotal figures in Superman’s story.
James Gunn and his decision to make Ma and Pa Kent the stupid rednecks. That’s a choice. And Superman has to be saved, like, repeatedly? On a movie this size, every decision is a choice made carefully,
Dean Cain said in his recent review of the film.
Comments on Collaborations and Personal Connections within DC Studios
Dean Cain also touched on his longstanding connection to Peter Safran, James Gunn’s partner in DC Studios. Despite Safran attending Princeton a year ahead of Cain, the actor pointed out with some disappointment that he has yet to be employed by the studio.
And Peter Safran is a Princeton guy, too, a year ahead of me, but he’s never hired me.
—Dean Cain
Disagreement with Gunn’s Interpretation of Superman’s Identity
Beyond the recent film’s characterization, Cain has previously voiced his disapproval of Gunn’s portrayal of Superman as an immigrant figure. Cain emphasized the importance of preserving the traditional values tied to the character, pointing out that while the American way is welcoming to immigrants, the original ideals should not be discarded.
He remarked,
“I think if you want to create a new character, go ahead and do that. But for me, Superman has always stood for ‘truth, justice, and the American way’ — and the American way is tremendously immigrant-friendly. But there are rules.”
Positive Moments in the Film and Overall Impression
Despite his criticisms, Cain found aspects of the movie that resonated with him, particularly involving Superman’s companion, Krypto. He appreciated the portrayal of Krypto’s heroism in small, compassionate acts that complemented the film’s broader narrative.
Seeing Krypto in the trailer gave me goose bumps. He saves a squirrel. He saves a little girl. I respect that,
he explained.
Dean Cain’s firm critique underscores a divide in opinion between former Superman actors and current DCU creative directions, raising questions about how legacy characters are evolving. His insights may influence future discussions on character development and storytelling within the DC film franchise, especially for long-standing fan favorites like Superman.
