Apple TV+ has confirmed Jack Reynor, known for his role in Midsommar, as the male lead for the highly anticipated Presumed Innocent season 2, starring opposite Rachel Brosnahan. This legal thriller series is based on the 1987 novel by Scott Turow, and the new season is set to adapt a case from Jo Murray’s book Dissection of a Murder.
Reynor’s notable credits include playing Christian in Midsommar, Shane in Transformers: Age of Extinction, and Thomas Winbury in Netflix’s The Perfect Couple. Brosnahan was cast earlier this year, following season 1’s star Jake Gyllenhaal. Though Reynor’s character details remain undisclosed, his involvement marks a fresh chapter for the series on Apple TV+.
Transition to an Anthology Format for the Series’ Second Season
With Jake Gyllenhaal not returning, Presumed Innocent season 2 will adopt an anthology structure, featuring an entirely new storyline and cast. While the main characters will differ, the possibility of some recurring peripheral characters remains open. This shift offers the series a chance to explore different legal cases within the same thematic universe.
The anthology approach aligns with Apple TV+’s strategy to deliver diverse legal dramas, especially as viewers wait for upcoming seasons of similar shows like The Lincoln Lawyer. Reynor’s casting signals a continuation of the show‘s intense and complex tone, although specific plot details for season 2 are still under wraps.
New Cast Brings Fresh Energy to the Evolving Series
Season 1 of Presumed Innocent introduced a gripping legal world, albeit with some imperfections, and its strong premise made it ripe for expansion. The addition of talented leads such as Jack Reynor and Rachel Brosnahan promises to elevate the show further, enhancing its dramatic appeal and deepening character portrayals.
While the future of the series beyond season 2 is uncertain, early indicators suggest the new installment will attract positive attention and improve the show’s overall reputation. How heavily the season leans into the anthology format will become clearer as the story unfolds, but the fresh cast lineup is generating hopeful anticipation among viewers.
“Reynor is a great choice for a male lead and many of his previous characters are in line with the tone and world of the show’s first season.” —Deadline source
As Presumed Innocent season 2 develops, the combination of Brosnahan and Reynor should bring a compelling dynamic to the screen, strengthening the series’ position in Apple TV+’s lineup of legal dramas and maintaining its connection to Scott Turow’s celebrated literary work.
