Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man 4 envisioned as a father, balancing superhero duties in Mattson Tomlin's intriguing concept.
Mattson Tomlin, co-writer of The Batman 2, recently shared his idea for a Spider-Man 4 featuring Tobey Maguire, focusing on Peter Parker’s role as a husband and father. Speaking during a social media Q&A on July 30, 2025, Tomlin expressed a desire to explore a new chapter in the character’s story that showcases the challenges of parenthood alongside superhero duties. Although he is not officially connected to any Marvel or Sony Spider-Man projects, he outlined this personal vision in response to fan questions about the future of Spider-Man’s journey.
When asked about his approach to the character, Tomlin said,
“Honestly right now my main interest in this respect would be to write a Spider-Man 4 where Tobey’s Spider-Man is juggling being a husband and a father. Spider-Man as a father is where I gravitate towards given the last 8 films.”
—mattson tomlin, Co-writer of The Batman 2
This perspective reflects a desire to evolve the storyline beyond traditional superhero conflicts, delving into Peter Parker’s life off the streets as he manages family responsibilities and superhero challenges simultaneously.
Fan Enthusiasm Surges for a Fourth Tobey Maguire Spider-Man Film
Following Tomlin’s announcement, fans eagerly responded on social media, expressing support for this potential direction. Many voiced excitement about revisiting the well-loved Sam Raimi Spider-Man universe through this deeper, more mature portrayal of Peter Parker. One fan remarked,
“A fourth film with Tobey as a father would be too perfect to conclude the story of the best Peter Parker.”
—Fan
Another commented,
“I’m all for a Tobey Spider-Man 4 movie. He is the Spider-Man I grew up with and I will go support it.”
—Fan
The discussion also included calls for Sony to move forward with the idea, citing the successful re-release of the Raimi trilogy as evidence of lasting fan interest. One user told Sony,
Image of: Tobey Maguire
“If DC can have two live action Batmen at once, the same can be done with Spider-Man. You guys re-release the Raimi Trilogy in theaters year by year to smashing successes every single time. Make Spider-Man 4 with Sam Raimi, its a money machine.Mr Tomlin, good luck!”
—Morals, Social Media User
Some fans also suggested recasting certain roles, such as Mary Jane, while expressing continued affection for Tobey Maguire’s portrayal.
Uncertainty Remains as Studios Have Yet to Respond
Despite the growing excitement, neither Sony nor Marvel Studios has publicly commented on Tomlin’s proposal or the idea of revisiting Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man for a fourth film. The absence of an official statement leaves the project’s future uncertain, but the discussion has sparked renewed interest in the character’s legacy and the potential pathways for his story.
This concept of portraying Peter Parker as a father could offer a mature and heartfelt evolution to the Spider-Man saga, distinguishing Tobey Maguire’s version with fresh emotional depth. If pursued, it may bridge the nostalgic appeal of the Raimi trilogy with contemporary storytelling that resonates with longtime fans. Tobey Maguire Spider-Man 4 father themes could open compelling narratives about balancing heroism with family life, challenging Peter Parker in new and meaningful ways.
