Adam Sandler’s widely criticized 2011 film, Jack and Jill, is now available for streaming on Starz as of August. Known for being one of the most negatively reviewed films in Sandler’s career, this comedy has drawn frustration from movie fans and critics alike, reflected in its extremely low ratings on review aggregator platforms. Despite Sandler’s usual comedic success, Jack and Jill’s reception has tested even the most patient viewers.
Reluctant fans of Sandler, or followers of actors like Al Pacino or Katie Holmes, who wish to complete their film collections, can now watch this controversial movie on Starz. On Rotten Tomatoes, Jack and Jill holds a dire 3% critic rating and a 36% audience score, with some suggesting even these numbers might be too generous. The film’s plot follows Jack, an advertising executive, who reluctantly welcomes his twin sister Jill — both roles played by Sandler — for the Thanksgiving holiday, only to face ongoing chaos when Jill’s interactions complicate Jack’s efforts to secure a commercial deal involving Al Pacino.
“Thanksgiving is usually a happy time, but ad executive Jack (Sandler) dreads the holiday because his twin sister, Jill (also Sandler), makes her annual visit. When Jack and his sister get off on the wrong foot, the only way to make it right is to invite her to stay through Hanukkah. But, when actor Al Pacino, whom Jack desperately needs to star in a commercial, takes a shine to Jill, Jack may be forced to extend his sister’s visit even longer.”
—Film Synopsis
Why ‘Jack and Jill’ Struggled at the Box Office Despite a Big Budget
Jack and Jill did not achieve the success typically expected given its $79 million production budget. The film’s awkward premise and overwhelmingly negative reviews hindered its performance, although it did manage to earn a total of $150 million worldwide. This figure includes a $74 million domestic gross paired with $76 million from international markets, nearly doubling its costs but falling short of a strong financial triumph. The movie lingered in theaters for 16 weeks, ending its run with a mere $80,000 during the final weekend, reflecting weak continuing interest.
This disappointing box office response highlights the risk inherent in comedies that divide opinion so harshly, especially when they involve high-profile stars like Sandler and Pacino. Jack and Jill’s commercial fate illustrates how poor critical perception can dampen even the potential audience draw of notable actors.
What Viewers Can Expect from ‘Jack and Jill’ on Starz
Now that Jack and Jill is on Starz, curious viewers can revisit or experience for the first time what many have called Adam Sandler’s most challenging movie. Fans of Sandler’s broader work may see this as a necessary step to completing his filmography, despite the film’s reputation for “fair stupidity” and lasting critical disdain. Including Al Pacino and Katie Holmes in the cast adds an element of star power that contrasts sharply with the movie’s bleak reception.
For those brave enough to watch, Jack and Jill offers a unique, if frustrating, blend of holiday family antics with Sandler’s double role and the unexpected participation of Pacino, who becomes involved in the story’s odd extended stay scenario. Whether viewers find humor or disappointment, the film remains a notable part of early 2010s comedy history.
