James Gunn addressed the rising toxicity in parts of the DC fandom following unsettling incidents at San Diego Comic-Con, where some fans reacted negatively to changes in the DC Cinematic Universe. An individual threatened to confront Gunn during the Peacemaker Season 2 panel, intending to approach the DC Studios co-chair aggressively. Although Gunn initially dismissed the threat as unrealistic given the large crowd at Hall H, the episode highlighted a troubling trend of hostility within the fan base.
Encouraging Fans to Avoid Engaging with Toxicity
Gunn emphasized that interacting with toxic behavior online only amplifies its impact. He shared his perspective on why some platforms seem less hostile, explaining that allowing toxic voices to speak unchecked and then ignoring them diminishes their influence.
“It isn’t because there are fewer toxic people here (although there seemingly are), it’s because it started as an online culture more willing to let the toxic personality in the back of the room shout himself hoarse and go away. When you shout back, you’re making that voice relevant,”
he explained.
Distinguishing Between Reasonable Criticism and Toxic Rage
He clarified that his focus is on condemning rage and cruelty, not on disagreements or thoughtful debates about creative choices.
“And, to be clear, when I’m talking about toxicity, I’m talking primarily about rage or cruelty. I’m not talking about not liking something or having reasonable arguments about things we like and don’t. Anyway, forgive the PSA, but it’s on my mind,”
Gunn added. His statements highlight the importance of separating genuine fan feedback from vitriolic attacks that undermine constructive discussions.
The Need for Healthier Fan Engagement Moving Forward
Despite facing backlash since taking leadership at DC Studios, Gunn remains focused on fostering a more positive environment among fans. He condemns using fandom as a tool to spread hatred, calling such behavior “stupid.” Gunn urges everyone to remember that stories and characters are meant to be enjoyable escapes rather than causes for real-world conflict. He encourages fans to calm down and appreciate the entertainment, rather than turning passion into hostility.
