Liam Neeson Criticizes Qui-Gon Jinn’s “Namby-Pamby” Death in Star Wars: The Phantom Menace

Before the release of the Obi-Wan Kenobi series in 2022, many Star Wars enthusiasts hoped Liam Neeson would return as Qui-Gon Jinn. Despite the Jedi Master’s death at Darth Maul’s hands in The Phantom Menace, fans felt it was lacking to continue Ben Kenobi’s story without an appearance from his former mentor’s Force Ghost. Ultimately, the show’s finale satisfied viewers by featuring a reunion that indicated Qui-Gon’s new path beyond death. The discussion around Liam Neeson Qui-Gon Jinn death remains a point of interest among fans.

Actor’s Candid Thoughts on His Character’s Demise

Liam Neeson has embraced his role within the Star Wars universe, lending his voice to Qui-Gon Jinn in The Clone Wars animated series and Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. However, he recently expressed dissatisfaction with how his character’s death was portrayed in The Phantom Menace. The actor criticized the scene as overly weak for someone depicted as a Master Jedi.

I thought my death was a bit namby-pamby,

Neeson said.

I was supposed to be a Master Jedi, you know? My character fell for that, ‘Oh I’m going for your face! No, I’m not I’m going for your stomach!’ ‘Oh, you got me!’ I was like oh, please. Hardly a Master Jedi.

—Liam Neeson, Actor

Liam Neeson
Image of: Liam Neeson

Insights into George Lucas’s Directorial Approach

Despite his criticisms, Neeson confirmed that working on the film was an enjoyable experience. He also shared a revealing perspective on Star Wars creator George Lucas’s feelings about directing. According to Neeson, Lucas prefers the post-production editing process rather than directing actors on set.

George doesn’t like directing. Period. He told me that,

Neeson revealed.

He’d finish a scene, he’d say, ‘Natalie, a little bit faster. Liam, a little bit faster there.’ [In the] editing suite afterwards, that’s when he starts enjoying the process. But actually directing actors and stuff, he told me he doesn’t like it.

—Liam Neeson, Actor

This insight may clarify why Lucas has not directed a movie since Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith in 2005. After selling Lucasfilm to Disney in 2012, Lucas had limited creative input on the subsequent Star Wars films and the Indiana Jones franchise, only making occasional set visits.

Neeson’s Reluctance to Reprise His Role Again

When asked about a potential return to the Star Wars universe, Neeson reflected on his past collaboration with Ewan McGregor and George Lucas. Although he cherishes the memories of filming The Phantom Menace 26 years ago, he expressed doubts about coming back due to his age and the practical challenges of reprising the role.

I enjoyed very much being with Ewan and George Lucas on The Phantom Menace. We shot that 26 years ago! Would I do it again? I don’t think so. Too ******* old, ya know? I can’t see the situation, I really can’t, you know?

—Liam Neeson, Actor

Lasting Impact of Qui-Gon Jinn’s Story

Liam Neeson’s frank views on Qui-Gon Jinn’s death and the behind-the-scenes look at George Lucas’s directing style offer new depth to the iconic character and the franchise’s production. While Neeson may step away from further Star Wars involvement, the legacy of Qui-Gon’s role remains influential within the saga. Fans continue to appreciate how his character shaped the narratives of Obi-Wan Kenobi and beyond, marking a lasting impact on the Star Wars storyline.