Ben Affleck & Matt Damon Nearly Faced Off as Enemies in $30.6M Flop The Last Duel—What Went Wrong?

The Last Duel represents another notable collaboration between Ben Affleck and Matt Damon, centered on a medieval story of accusation and vengeance. Originally, the film intended to feature Affleck and Damon as adversaries for the first time on screen. Both actors, known for their strong partnership since their early days as extras in Field of Dreams, have appeared together in ten films, frequently portraying close friends or allies rather than enemies. The Last Duel, starring Damon as Jean de Carrouges and directed by Ridley Scott, is based on a true story where a duel determines the fate of honor and truth.

During the film’s development, Affleck was cast as Jacques le Gris, the rival knight accused of assaulting Carrouges’ wife, Marguerite, played by Jodie Comer. Affleck and Damon co-wrote the screenplay with Nicole Holofcener​​​​​, crafting the narrative through three perspectives—the victim, the accused, and the accuser—which built up to a climactic duel in which only one could survive. This setup would have marked a fresh dynamic in their illustrious careers, pitting them against each other for dramatic conflict.

However, Affleck had to relinquish the leading role of Jacques le Gris due to scheduling conflicts with his work on Deep Water, as reported by Variety. Adam Driver then stepped into the role of le Gris, and Affleck assumed a smaller supporting part as Count Pierre d’Alençon, a nobleman overseeing the feud between the knights. This shift altered the original vision of the film and Affleck and Damon sharing intense opposing roles.

Ben Affleck
Image of: Ben Affleck

The Rare On-Screen Rivalry Between Longtime Friends

Despite their extensive collaborative history, Ben Affleck and Matt Damon have seldom portrayed enemies. Their on-screen partnerships are largely defined by friendship and mutual support, most memorably in Good Will Hunting, which they co-wrote and starred in as close friends. Their chemistry as allies has become one of Hollywood’s defining duos.

Though they briefly embodied antagonistic roles early in their careers, such as playing rival antisemitic students in the 1990s drama School Ties, and as estranged fallen angels in Dogma, neither film positioned them as direct enemies in a central conflict. The Last Duel hinted at this dynamic when Affleck’s Count Pierre expressed disdain for Damon’s Jean de Carrouges, but their shared screen time remained limited.

The missed chance for an Affleck-Damon faceoff in the film’s brutal final duel feels like a lost opportunity, considering their long-standing connection and dramatic potential. Both actors are set to reunite in the forthcoming crime thriller The Rip, though details about their roles and relationship in this new project remain under wraps. Fans of their work eagerly anticipate the possibility of a true, intense confrontation between these close friends on screen in the future.

The Last Duel’s Cast and Creative Team

The major roles in The Last Duel feature Matt Damon as the wronged knight Jean de Carrouges and Adam Driver as Jacques le Gris, the accused nobleman. Jodie Comer portrays Marguerite, whose accusation sparks the deadly duel. Ben Affleck plays Count Pierre d’Alençon, a figure overseeing the conflict. Michael McElhatton also appears in a supporting role. The screenplay was a joint effort by Affleck, Damon, and Nicole Holofcener​​​​​, directed by Ridley Scott, bringing a multi-layered perspective to the medieval story.

The Last Duel’s Performance and Legacy

Although The Last Duel did not achieve box office success, grossing approximately $30.6 million, it remains a significant entry in both Affleck’s and Damon’s careers for its ambitious storytelling and historical backdrop. The film’s unique narrative structure and nuanced performances received appreciation, even if broader audiences did not embrace it financially. The collaboration between Affleck and Damon, despite being altered from the original plan, added a notable chapter to their enduring partnership in Hollywood.

The question of what could have been—Affleck and Damon facing each other in a gripping duel—adds intrigue to the film’s legacy. Their creative willingness to take on complex roles, co-writing the film and sharing the screen, reflects their commitment to storytelling beyond conventional expectations. As their careers continue to evolve, the possibility of an on-screen rivalry remains a compelling prospect for future projects.