When DC Studios announced its lineup for Chapter 1: Gods and Monsters early in 2023, The Brave and the Bold stood out as an unexpected addition. Instead of focusing on Batman alone, the story will delve into the hero mentoring his son, Damian, as Robin. With Matt Reeves’ The Batman Part II scheduled for release in 2027, and DC Studios co-CEO James Gunn confirming Robert Pattinson will not continue as Batman in the DCU, the question arises: who will take over the iconic role? The search is for an actor who embodies a seasoned, complex Batman capable of balancing the role of Gotham’s protector and a father figure.
The role of Bruce Wayne is notoriously challenging, with a legacy of intense portrayals. The new Batman in The Brave and the Bold is anticipated to be more experienced and mature than some previous versions, suggesting the casting will favor actors who can convey a darker, multifaceted character. Below are seven actors who could potentially become Robert Pattinson’s Batman replacement, each bringing a unique blend of experience and style.
Richard Madden’s Potential as a Confident and Strategic Batman
Richard Madden, known widely for his role as Ikaris in the MCU’s Eternals, presents an intriguing choice for the Dark Knight. Although his fate in the MCU seemed limited, this may open opportunities for him in the DC universe. Madden’s classic look fits the traditional image of Bruce Wayne, with a strong presence that suggests he could wear the cowl with undeniable authority.
More importantly, Madden has proven his versatility and depth in projects like Game of Thrones and Bodyguard. His ability to portray darker, conflicted characters suggests he could convincingly embody Batman’s internal struggles and strategic brilliance. Batman is often portrayed as the smartest person in the room, capable of outthinking even his Justice League allies. Madden’s portrayal could offer a Batman with a mix of charisma and brooding intensity, capable of carrying the weight of a hardened protector and father.
Brandon Sklenar as a Grounded, Experienced Guardian of Gotham
Brandon Sklenar, known for his roles in It Ends with Us and Drop, has quickly become a fan favorite for the Batman role in the DCU. With a look and demeanor more reminiscent of earlier Batman portrayals by Michael Keaton, Christian Bale, and Ben Affleck, Sklenar fits the template for a traditional yet nuanced Dark Knight. This alignment is significant as it aligns with the DCU’s direction for The Brave and the Bold, presenting a veteran Batman who has spent years protecting Gotham.
Sklenar’s appeal lies not only in his acting skills but also in his suitability as a father figure, crucial in a storyline centering on his relationship with Damian Wayne. Additionally, his Batman could extend his influence to characters like Dick Grayson and Barbara Gordon, providing a mentor role that is both tough and tender. His style promises a return to the grounded, complex Batman who stands firmly against Gotham’s dangers while nurturing the next generation.
Taron Egerton’s Blend of Action and Emotional Depth
Taron Egerton, a name often considered for major superhero roles like Spider-Man and Wolverine, carries immense potential to portray Batman. His performances in Rocketman, Black Bird, and Carry On have established him as a versatile actor capable of handling complex emotional arcs and action sequences with equal skill.
Though Egerton and Pattinson share a nationality, their acting approaches differ markedly. Egerton presents a more classical heroism that could align well with fans desiring a comicbook-accurate Batman. His experience in action and character-driven drama suggests he can balance the physical demands of the fight scenes with the psychological depth required for Bruce Wayne’s complicated life, especially when handling the pressures of fatherhood and crimefighting.
Luke Evans as a Tough and Layered Batman Figure
Luke Evans remains one of Hollywood’s most underrated talents, particularly due to his absence from superhero franchises until now. The DCU’s reboot offers an opportunity for Evans to take on a Batman role that leans into a rougher, no-nonsense vigilante personality, which could evolve into a softer, more fatherly presence as his story unfolds.
Evans’ capacity to play characters who balance grit and vulnerability would enrich the Batman narrative, especially as the character navigates his responsibilities to both Gotham and his son, Damian. Visualizing Evans in ensemble scenes alongside Superman and the Justice League feels natural, promising a Batman who is both imposing and emotionally accessible. His acting skills suggest the potential to bring innovative layers to this iteration of the Dark Knight.
Winston Duke’s Unique Take Rooted in Previous Batman Experience
Winston Duke, well recognized for his role as M’Baku in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, has displayed ample charisma and nuance, though some feel his talents have yet to be fully showcased. Duke’s previous involvement with Batman comes through his voice role in the acclaimed podcast series Batman Unburied, where he delivered a strong performance as the Caped Crusader.
Duke’s casting would represent a fresh and exciting expansion for Batman on screen, embracing diversity without making it the central focus. A Black Bruce Wayne is an opportunity for broader representation, and it could open doors for diverse actors to fill key roles such as Robin. Additionally, Duke’s acclaimed work in films like Nine Days and Us underscores his ability to handle complex, emotionally rich characters, making him a compelling candidate for the role.
Lee Pace’s Strength and Complexity for a Seasoned Batman
Lee Pace’s collaboration with James Gunn on Guardians of the Galaxy, where he portrayed Ronan the Accuser, positions him advantageously among these candidates. Pace is known for his commanding presence and his performances across series like Halt and Catch Fire and Foundation, as well as his role in The Hobbit trilogy, which have all demonstrated his range and physicality.
Given The Brave and the Bold will likely depict a battle-hardened Batman coming to terms with fatherhood, Pace could bring the appropriate blend of gravitas and vulnerability. If director James Gunn draws inspiration from writer Grant Morrison’s influential Batman stories, the actor must balance darkness, eccentricity, and moments of levity. Pace appears suited to balancing these elements effectively.
Jensen Ackles as a Fan-Favorite Ready to Lead
Jensen Ackles’ journey from his role as Dean Winchester on Supernatural to prominent parts in The Boys and Countdown has showcased his growth and versatility. Having voiced Batman in several animated projects, Ackles has openly expressed his desire to portray the character live-action, which sets him apart as a genuine fan favorite for this role.
Ackles’ casting would please many fans craving a familiar face deeply connected to the character, yet DC Studios is also looking to expand beyond only A-list stars, as evidenced by the casting of David Corenswet as Superman. Ackles combines charisma and dedication, making him a strong contender to embody a Batman who carries the legacy while adding fresh layers to the role, especially as he navigates personal and heroic challenges.
With Robert Pattinson stepping away from the role, DC Studios faces the complex task of casting a Batman capable of standing apart while honoring the character’s vast legacy within the DC universe. Each of these actors brings something distinct to the table, from seasoned emotional depth to physical presence and a connection to Batman’s darker themes. The chosen actor will help define the future of Batman’s story in The Brave and the Bold and beyond, shaping the character’s evolution as both Gotham’s defender and a father figure in the evolving DCU landscape.
