David Corenswet stars in the captivating film The Greatest Hits, a time travel romance currently streaming on Hulu. The movie, directed by Ned Benson, combines elements of music and science fiction to tell a poignant story about love, loss, and the passage of time. Corenswet, known for his roles in television projects with Ryan Murphy and the recent film Twisters, delivers a compelling performance that deserves wider recognition.
The film follows Harriet, played by Lucy Boynton, who survives a car crash that tragically claims her boyfriend Max, portrayed by Corenswet. After the accident, Harriet experiences a unique and haunting side effect: whenever she hears songs that were meaningful to their relationship, her consciousness transports her back to the moments they shared together. This connection allows her to relive those memories and fuels her repeated attempts to save Max from his fate.
The Bittersweet Struggle to Change Fate
Harriet’s visits to the past are filled with tender and bittersweet encounters, revealing why she fell in love with Max in the first place. Yet despite her persistent efforts, she is unable to alter the outcome, leading to a painful sense of frustration. To cope, Harriet joins a grief support group where she begins to openly express her feelings. It is there she meets David, played by Justin H. Min, who offers her a chance at healing and moving forward.

This emotional crossroads forces Harriet to confront a difficult choice: to continue clinging to the past or embrace the possibility of a new future. The story captures the tension between holding on and letting go, with Corenswet’s magnetic presence enhancing the depth of this journey.
Finding the Strength to Let Go
Throughout the film, every return to the past deepens the audience’s connection to Harriet‘s sorrow and longing. Boynton’s portrayal makes Harriet’s grief tangible, while Corenswet’s natural charm enriches the chemistry between the couple. Their interactions are both heartwarming and heartrending, making the viewer root for Max’s survival with earnest hope.
The film’s powerful message centers on acceptance and release. Harriet‘s realization that she cannot save Max without ultimately letting him go resonates profoundly. As one memorable line states,
you can’t always get what you want.
—Ned Benson, Director
This insight leads Harriet to allow Max’s memory to live on, while opening herself up to new possibilities with David. The film explores the reality that love is not always singular and that healing often requires embracing change.
A Memorable Musical and Sci-Fi Romance
The Greatest Hits stands out as an unconventional romantic comedy that lingers in the mind well after the credits roll. It skillfully weaves grief, music, and soft science fiction to tell a story that feels both intimate and universal. The soundtrack plays a crucial role, providing emotional anchors that trigger Harriet’s journeys through time.
Benson’s script and direction are complemented by standout performances from Boynton and Corenswet, whose onscreen chemistry brings authenticity to this extraordinary narrative. As Corenswet rises in fame through his role as Superman, this film marks a significant early highlight in his career that audiences should actively seek out.
By exploring themes of love, loss, and the courage to move forward, The Greatest Hits offers a hopeful and heartfelt experience. With its unique mix of genres and emotional depth, it is a must-watch for fans of David Corenswet and those drawn to stories about the complexities of the human heart.