The CW‘s hit series The Vampire Diaries, which ran for eight seasons from 2009 to 2017, almost featured Jason Momoa in one of its iconic roles. Centered around a young woman who falls in love with an immortal being, the show was adapted from L. J. Smith’s young adult novels. Momoa auditioned for the part of Alaric Saltzman, a vampire hunter who becomes an important character throughout the series. This surprising casting information reveals how different the show could have been.
The series stars a strong ensemble cast including Nina Dobrev, Paul Wesley, Ian Somerhalder, Steven R. McQueen, Sara Canning, Kat Graham, Candice King, and Matthew Davis, who ultimately earned the role of Alaric Saltzman. Known for his memorable portrayal, Davis’s character is a favorite especially during the early seasons of the show. Alongside Momoa, Joe Manganiello, another actor connected to vampire television through True Blood, also auditioned for the same role.
How Jason Momoa’s Potential Involvement Might Have Changed Career Paths and the Series
Jason Momoa’s career gained significant momentum following his performances in Game of Thrones and the 2011 film Conan the Barbarian. He later achieved widespread acclaim as Aquaman in DC’s superhero franchise. Had he been cast as Alaric Saltzman in The Vampire Diaries, Momoa’s career might have taken a different direction, potentially altering the action-star trajectory he is known for today.

Kevin Williamson, co-developer of The Vampire Diaries and writer of the original Scream film, created a show that balanced supernatural drama with strong character development. The series’ run over nearly a decade established its fanbase and cultural impact. While The Vampire Diaries could have solidified Momoa’s fame in a different genre, it’s likely he might have missed the defining roles that propelled him to action stardom.
Similarly, the dynamic on-screen chemistry and tone of the series would have varied considerably without Matthew Davis as Alaric. Davis not only helped to shape the character but also contributed to the overall popularity of the show. His portrayal remains memorable to fans, highlighting how casting choices influence a series’ success.
Comparing the Acting Styles and Impacts of Matthew Davis and Jason Momoa
Matthew Davis and Jason Momoa offer very different strengths as actors, which would have affected the character of Alaric Saltzman. Davis’s boy-next-door charm and subtle approach give Alaric a relatable quality, balancing the supernatural elements with grounded emotion. Momoa’s more rugged and macho presence, while versatile, would have created a different tone for the character and the series as a whole.
Ultimately, it appears fortunate that Jason Momoa did not secure the role of Alaric. Davis delivers a performance that many fans consider one of the series’ highlights. This casting allowed Momoa to pursue roles better suited to his talents, such as Aquaman and other iconic characters, enhancing both his career and the shows he stars in. The distinct paths taken by each actor underline how casting decisions shape both individual careers and the entertainment projects themselves.
The Core Story and Cast Behind The Vampire Diaries
Based on L. J. Smith’s novels, The Vampire Diaries follows the complex love triangle between Elena Gilbert and vampire brothers Stefan and Damon Salvatore in the fictional town of Mystic Falls, Virginia. The show charts their relationships from high school into college, weaving supernatural conflicts and emotional struggles.
Key cast members include Paul Wesley as Stefan Salvatore and Ian Somerhalder as Damon Salvatore, whose performances helped anchor the series. The ensemble, combined with characters like Alaric Saltzman, created a compelling narrative that captivated viewers for eight seasons, blending romance and fantasy in a small-town setting.
