In 1984, Michael J. Fox, then starring as Alex P. Keaton on the hit TV series Family Ties, was unexpectedly kept from accepting the lead role in Back to the Future. Family Ties creator Gary David Goldberg, prioritizing Fox’s television obligations, secretly declined the role for him, delaying his involvement in the iconic film. This behind-the-scenes decision altered the movie’s early casting and Fox’s career trajectory.
The Initial Casting and Goldberg’s Confidential Rejection
Before Michael J. Fox became synonymous with Marty McFly, the role was initially given to Eric Stoltz. Stoltz’s portrayal, however, did not capture the comedic energy the filmmakers wanted. Meanwhile, Fox was unaware that Steven Spielberg and Robert Zemeckis had approached Goldberg to release him for the movie, but Goldberg refused. Fox explained,
“They wanted to go in October, and he couldn’t let me out,”
adding,
“He had said, ‘I can’t let him do it. Please don’t tel Michael — not that I want him to think I did something behind his back, but I really have no other choice.’ And I totally accept that and understand that.”
Fox’s Balancing Act: Juggling Television and Film
Fox, who was focused on his television career, initially welcomed the idea of starring in Back to the Future, even remarking during a break on Teen Wolf,
“That would be great. If I could do that, that would be a lot better than being a werewolf.”
However, with his TV commitments preventing immediate participation, Fox was called back to Goldberg’s office after the holiday break and given the script for Back to the Future. Goldberg encouraged him, stating,
“Steven Spielberg is producing this film, Bob Zemeckis is directing it. They want you to do it, so why don’t you take it and read it. And if you want to do it, we’ll figure out how to make it work.”
Once on board, Fox managed a grueling schedule, filming Family Ties during the day and Back to the Future at night, sometimes working up to 20 hours daily. Reflecting on the challenge, Fox admitted,
“It took me a long time to believe that I pulled it off.”
The Impact of Fox’s Performance and the Film’s Success
Fox’s eventual casting brought the playful, quirky Marty McFly to life, helping transform Back to the Future into a beloved cultural milestone. The film’s success spawned multiple sequels and solidified Fox’s film career. Meanwhile, the initial hesitation from Goldberg and the interim casting of Stoltz remain lesser-known parts of Hollywood history that highlight the complexities actors often face balancing TV and film work.
Legacy of a Career Choice and Ongoing Popularity
Michael J. Fox’s determination to take on the role despite the exhausting schedule underlines his commitment and the importance of opportunity timing in the entertainment industry. His portrayal continues to be celebrated, and the story behind the casting sheds light on the influence producers wield over actors’ choices. As Fox’s career evolved, his success in both television and film stands as a testament to perseverance and talent navigating unexpected hurdles.
