The first images of John Lithgow as Albus Dumbledore in the upcoming Harry Potter TV remake have reignited longstanding discussions about the character’s portrayal. This new interpretation, revealed through behind-the-scenes photos, sheds light on which prior Dumbledore portrayal Lithgow’s version most closely aligns with, helping fans gauge its faithfulness to the beloved books and past performances.
John Lithgow’s Appearance Reflects Richard Harris’ Original Dumbledore Style
John Lithgow underwent a dramatic transformation for his role in the Harry Potter series remake, shown in set photos that highlight his costume and styling. Lithgow is seen wearing long, richly detailed robes and a flowing silver beard extending nearly to his knees. His hair is styled in a full silver wig pulled back into a low ponytail, perfectly accessorized with the iconic half-moon spectacles perched low on his nose.
This presentation bears a striking resemblance to Richard Harris’ portrayal of Dumbledore in the first two Harry Potter films. Harris’ Hogwarts headmaster costume was known for its flamboyance and mystical qualities, complete with long hair and an elaborate beard. In contrast, Michael Gambon’s version that followed was marked by simpler, more subdued robes in greyish-blue tones, shorter curly hair, and a braided beard, lacking the same theatrical flourish. Gambon often forewent the half-moon glasses entirely.
The comparison of Lithgow’s costume to Harris’ and Gambon’s reveals clear distinctions: Lithgow’s look distinctly echoes the ornate and wizard-like style originally associated with Harris, rather than the more utilitarian and pragmatic aesthetic established by Gambon.
New Dumbledore Look Supports Arguments Favoring Richard Harris’ Faithfulness to the Books
Since Michael Gambon stepped into the role after Richard Harris’ passing, Harry Potter fans have debated which actor better captured the essence of Albus Dumbledore. Harris’ portrayal reflected a character with long, silvery hair and a penetrating gaze, aligning closely with J.K. Rowling’s descriptions. Gambon’s performance, however, brought a livelier and more dynamic presence, supported by a costume that allowed greater ease of movement.
Neither actor perfectly embodied every aspect detailed in the books. However, the recent decision by HBO to adopt a costume style akin to Harris’ signals a deliberate effort to embrace a more authentic book-accurate visual representation of the character. The set images further affirm HBO’s intent to remain faithful to the original material, as shown by scenes such as Vernon Dursley being warmly greeted by a young wizard on the street—a moment cut from the movies—and a reimagined visit to the zoo involving Dudley and a friend, differing from earlier adaptations.
Lithgow’s Dumbledore, with his elaborately embroidered robes and lengthy silver hair and beard, captures one of the defining features of the wizard as penned in the books. How well Lithgow will embody Dumbledore’s complex mannerisms remains to be seen, but visually, the costume design reinforces the show’s commitment to honoring the source material.
John Lithgow’s Casting Suggests a Blend of Richard Harris’ Look and Michael Gambon’s Energy
John Lithgow’s casting as Dumbledore surprised some fans given his usual on-screen personas, but the new images dispel doubts by confirming his character’s visual association with Richard Harris’ Dumbledore. With a look that closely mirrors Harris’ wizardly appearance, Lithgow’s portrayal is poised to strike an intriguing balance.
While Harris presented Dumbledore with a quiet eccentricity, Gambon infused the role with a robust energy and dynamism. Lithgow, known for his animated and expressive acting style, is expected to bring this vibrancy, potentially merging Harris’ visual accuracy with Gambon’s spirited interpretation. This blend aligns with J.K. Rowling’s depiction of Dumbledore as both wise and lively, a figure far more than a typical elderly wizard.
The varied portrayals by Harris, Gambon, and now Lithgow have sparked ongoing debates about the “true” Dumbledore, each capturing different facets of the character’s personality and appearance. Lithgow’s introduction adds another dimension to this discussion, promising to honor the legacy of his predecessors while offering something fresh and compelling for audiences.
Insight into the New Cast and Production Details
The Harry Potter remake features Dominic McLaughlin as Harry Potter, Janet McTeer as Minerva McGonagall, John Lithgow as Albus Dumbledore, and Nick Frost as Hagrid. With such a talented cast assembled, the adaptation aims to breathe new life into familiar characters while bringing fans closer to the books’ intricate storytelling and atmospheres.
HBO’s ongoing commitment to a faithful adaptation is reflected not only in casting and costumes but also in the decision to include scenes and narrative elements previously excluded from the films. This approach is likely to deepen the series’ connection with longtime fans and attract new viewers intrigued by a fresh, richer experience of the wizarding world.
First look at John Lithgow as Dumbledore in the HBO Harry Potter show
Thoughts? pic.twitter.com/qh89ScYBSc
— MyTimeToShineHello (@MyTimeToShineH) October 8, 2025
