The Witcher Season 4 has arrived on Netflix, introducing Liam Hemsworth as the new Geralt of Rivia. This casting change follows Henry Cavill’s iconic portrayal, putting considerable pressure on Hemsworth to meet fan expectations. With the spotlight squarely on this switch, the question arises: who is the better Geralt, Henry Cavill or Liam Hemsworth?
While it’s important to recognize that each actor brings their own style to the role and has faced unique challenges behind the scenes, comparing their performances sheds light on how the show’s tone and characters have evolved. Both Cavill and Hemsworth have dedicated substantial effort to this demanding character, demonstrating their commitment in different ways.
Visual Impact and Costume Fit
The most immediate comparison lies in their appearances as Geralt. Both men are undeniably attractive, though their physical builds differ notably. Henry Cavill stands at 6’1” with a heavily muscular frame that gave his leather armor a tight, heroic fit, enhancing his imposing presence as a monster hunter. In contrast, Liam Hemsworth’s 6’3” stature and leaner build caused the Season 4 costume to appear somewhat loose, giving off a less tailored impression.
The wig, a vital part of Geralt’s signature look, also draws noticeable distinctions. Cavill’s silver hair suited him well, blending naturally into his strong portrayal, while Hemsworth’s wig has drawn criticism for its less convincing appearance and precarious fit, breaking the illusion for some viewers. This visual difference has triggered various reactions, from admiration of Cavill’s imposing silhouette to the joking comparison of Hemsworth to a “Spirit Halloween” version of the character.
Winner: Henry Cavill
Evolution of Geralt’s Personality
Geralt’s character development varies significantly between the two actors. Cavill’s Geralt largely embodied the archetype of the stoic lone wolf: detached, introspective, and reluctant to open up. His aloofness was fitting for the earlier seasons, aligning with the script’s focus on Geralt as a solitary figure burdened by his destiny and responsibilities.
Season 4’s storyline has allowed Hemsworth to portray a Geralt who is evolving emotionally. Hemsworth’s version reveals a softer side, showing Geralt as more vulnerable, communicative, and willing to accept the support of his hansa—a collective of allies and friends. This Geralt is no longer a mute warrior but someone who cautiously engages in meaningful conversations and even expresses moments of levity. These changes highlight the character’s growth and shift the dynamic within the show’s group.
Though Cavill laid the groundwork for Geralt’s emotional distance, Hemsworth’s interpretation offers a fresh take on his transformation, presenting a Geralt who begins to embrace his relationships, especially with Ciri, his adoptive daughter played by Freya Allan, and Yennefer, portrayed by Anya Chalotra.
Winner: Liam Hemsworth
The Power of Geralt’s Language
A peculiar but notable trait of Cavill’s interpretation was his gruff and impactful use of expletives, particularly his delivery of “fuck.” These utterances often punctuated intense scenes, adding emotional depth and a memorable edge to his character. Cavill made swearing an art form that conveyed frustration, sarcasm, or humor with authenticity.
Hemsworth’s approach to these moments is markedly different; his performance is softer and more approachable, losing some of that rawness and sharp impact that Cavill brought. While this gentler style aligns with the character’s evolving openness, it also diminishes the bite and intensity that fans appreciated in earlier seasons.
Winner: Henry Cavill
Combat and Action Sequences
The Witcher’s foundation rests heavily on thrilling action and monster battles, a domain where both Cavill and Hemsworth excel due to their backgrounds in major action franchises. Cavill’s Geralt demonstrated a visceral and fierce fighting style, showcasing his physicality with memorable, dynamic sword battles. His movements suggested a seasoned warrior prepared for brutal confrontation at any moment.
Hemsworth’s experience likewise supports a strong action presence, but Season 4 presents complications as Geralt is injured during much of the storyline. Consequently, his fighting scenes are limited, with many of the acrobatic displays handed over to Ciri and other characters. Despite this, the show included sequences reshot to feature Hemsworth in classic monster battles from prior seasons, maintaining the aggressive spirit of the combat.
Overall, their action portrayals are equally competent, although season circumstances have constrained Hemsworth’s opportunities to showcase Geralt’s full combat capabilities.
Winner: Tie
On-Screen Chemistry with Key Characters
Relationships are essential to Geralt’s narrative, especially the complex bonds with Ciri and Yennefer. Season 4’s script divides the main characters into separate story arcs, limiting Geralt’s time onscreen alongside Ciri. However, a crucial reunion with Yennefer late in the season invites close examination of Hemsworth’s chemistry with Anya Chalotra.
Unlike the electric rapport and depth that Cavill and Chalotra conveyed in prior seasons, Hemsworth’s interactions with Yennefer feel distant and underdeveloped. The much-anticipated romantic reunion lacks passion and intensity, coming across more as obligatory than genuine connection. Chalotra’s consistent dedication shines through, but the pairing does not capture the same emotional resonance as before, sometimes leaving the viewer with an impression of awkwardness rather than shared history or longing.
This dynamic contrast reduces the emotional weight of their scenes together, weakening the sense of star-crossed lovers that once defined their relationship.
“Hey, why aren’t Geralt and Yennefer hanging out”
– Anya Chalotra, Actress
Winner: Henry Cavill
Deciding the Superior Geralt
Choosing a definitive “better” Geralt is a complex task. Henry Cavill set a high standard with his deep immersion into the role, becoming synonymous with the White Wolf and bringing undeniable charisma and strength to his portrayal. His seasons, although sometimes a confusing narrative mess, were elevated by his commanding presence and memorable performances.
Conversely, Liam Hemsworth’s Geralt feels tailored for the narrative and tonal shifts underway in Season 4. The story embraces a fuller ensemble cast and explores more nuanced character relationships, with Hemsworth’s performance reflecting this evolution. While he may not eclipse Cavill in iconic status, Hemsworth infuses the show with a breath of fresh energy that aligns with its current creative direction.
In essence, Cavill remains the quintessential Geralt historically, but Hemsworth plays an essential role in pushing the series forward as it ventures into new storytelling terrain. Fans may prefer Cavill’s classic, rugged take, but Hemsworth’s contribution is pivotal for the show’s future phases.
With The Witcher Season 4 now streaming on Netflix, viewers can witness these differing interpretations and engage with the ongoing saga. As the show looks ahead to its final season, Hemsworth’s challenge will be to balance the legacy Cavill created while carving out his unique imprint as Geralt of Rivia.
