Guillermo del Toro’s latest adaptation, Guillermo del Toro Frankenstein, revisits Mary Shelley’s iconic 1818 novel with fresh eyes while acknowledging the shadow cast by previous versions such as James Whale’s 1931 film and its acclaimed sequel, as well as Mel Brooks’s comedic Young Frankenstein. Released on Netflix on November 7, 2025, this retelling blends deep emotion and lush visuals to breathe new life into the familiar story of Victor Frankenstein and his creation, making it a standout among the many interpretations of this timeless tale.
Plot Overview and Artistic Direction
The story unfolds aboard an icebound ship where Scandinavian sailors discover Baron Victor Frankenstein (Oscar Isaac), who recounts the events leading to his current predicament. Victor’s narrative touches on his strict upbringing by his imperious father (Charles Dance), the sorrow of his mother’s early death (Mia Goth), and the arrival of his idealistic brother William (Felix Kammerer). Fueled by his ambition to conquer death, Victor, supported financially by arms dealer Henrich Harlander, embarks on a dangerous journey to reanimate life. His romantic entanglement with Harlander’s niece, Elizabeth (also played by Mia Goth and William’s fiancée), adds complexity to his pursuits. The climax of Victor’s ambition is the creation of a nameless Creature (Jacob Elordi), whose struggles with learning and acceptance mark the beginning of profound challenges for his creator.
The Creature’s Voice and Unique Character Portrayal
Uniquely narrated in the second half by the Creature himself, del Toro’s version gives this traditionally voiceless figure a rich, articulate presence, aligning more directly with Shelley’s original novel than many film adaptations have dared. The Creature’s evolution includes learning to speak and forging a bond with a blind man (David Bradley). This layered portrayal is enhanced by intricate makeup and visual effects, with seams on Elordi’s imposing frame resembling speed lines, lending an almost kinetic beauty. This Creature conveys a profound tenderness, communicating deep loneliness and a yearning for acceptance beyond the many eloquent speeches he delivers.
A Distinctive Revision of Elizabeth’s Role
Elizabeth emerges as more than a mere extension of the Frankenstein brothers’ lives, portrayed with a compelling originality. Though introduced through her relationships with men, she defies the conventions of previous interpretations. Mia Goth’s performance harnesses her unique screen presence, evident also in her work on Pearl and Infinity Pool, to craft a character who resists societal norms, her expressions and mannerisms signaling her discomfort within polite society.
Oscar Isaac’s Complex Interpretation of Victor Frankenstein
Isaac’s portrayal of Victor Frankenstein is markedly intense and nuanced. Despite earlier criticism of his English accent in the Marvel series Moon Knight, here his clipped and refined delivery fits a manic, driven genius obsessed with proving godlike powers. His commanding presence anchors the film, particularly in a powerful scene where Victor faces an inquisition and defiantly challenges divine authority. This electrifying moment sets the tone for his relentless pursuit throughout the movie.
The Film’s Ambitious Scope and Narrative Challenges
While Isaac, Goth, and Elordi deliver passionate performances, the film’s storytelling sometimes falters. Spanning 150 minutes, Frankenstein excels in atmosphere and character development but feels rushed in its final 20 minutes. The climactic confrontation between creator and Creature, which carries immense emotional weight, lacks urgency. In addition, the film suddenly introduces themes of war, forgiveness, and regret in a way that feels tacked on rather than woven into the story’s fabric, diminishing the power of earlier scenes and leaving a discordant ending.
Visual Mastery and Atmospheric Design
Del Toro’s dedication to visual artistry shines throughout the film. Set against a Gothic backdrop, the production features cavernous, atmospheric sets and costumes rich with detail, particularly Elizabeth’s sumptuous dresses. The converted water station serving as Victor’s laboratory—with its central yawning hole—offers a haunting, symbolic setting for many key scenes. Cinematographer Dan Laustsen and production designer Tamara Deverell contribute significantly to creating a world that is as emotionally charged as its characters.
A Singular Take on an Enduring Tale
This adaptation of Frankenstein stands apart as a work deeply infused with Guillermo del Toro’s vision, combining empathy, horror, and beauty in unexpected ways. It is not the definitive retelling of the story about a man challenging the Almighty, nor does it entirely overcome its narrative shortcomings. However, it remains a distinctive and memorable iteration that reflects the filmmaker’s commitment to exploring monsters not just as creatures of fear, but as beings capable of profound humanity.
