James Gunn’s new Superman film, released this summer, presents a version of the iconic hero that challenges traditional ideas of masculinity. Starring David Corenswet as Superman and Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane, the movie highlights a gentler, more emotionally open Superman, in line with the focus on James Gunn Superman masculinity.
Therapist Jonathan Decker, featured on Cinema Therapy, points out that Corenswet’s portrayal avoids toxic masculinity by showing Clark Kent’s openness and honesty. This approach is particularly visible in Clark’s sincere conversations with Lois Lane, where he expresses his feelings clearly, creating space for her to understand her own emotions without confusion.
The Roots of Superman’s Non-Toxic Masculinity
Decker and filmmaker Alan Seawright explore how Superman’s balanced masculinity emerges from both his Kryptonian heritage and his upbringing by Jonathan and Martha Kent. Decker explains,
“His Kryptonian nature is where all of his powers come from. But his gentleness and his kindness and his regard for human life, this he gets from Jonathan and Martha [Kent].” – Jonathan Decker, Therapist
This blend of innate power and learned compassion is at the heart of Superman’s character in the film, distinguishing him from more traditionally aggressive portrayals of masculinity.
Superman’s Approach to Conflict Reflects Healthy Masculinity
The portrayal of Superman’s strength and combat style also supports the film’s theme of non-toxic masculinity. Rather than fighting out of aggression, Superman acts out of necessity and defense, demonstrating restraint and protecting others without unnecessary violence. Decker comments on this behavior, stating,
“Healthy masculinity, when it comes to fighting, is defensive, not aggressive.” – Jonathan Decker, Therapist
These moments emphasize the hero’s commitment to peace and protection rather than dominance, reinforcing the film’s more sensitive depiction of masculinity.
Critical and Audience Response to Gunn’s Superman
James Gunn’s Superman has been well received by both critics and viewers. The film’s vibrant visuals, strong performances from Corenswet and Brosnahan, and its hopeful, heartfelt narrative have resonated widely. On Rotten Tomatoes, the movie holds an 83% critic approval rating, while the audience score on Popcornmeter is even higher at 90%, reflecting broad appreciation for this take on the superhero.
The positive reception has also translated into commercial success, with the film grossing $615 million globally. This strong performance has encouraged DC to approve a sequel, with Gunn returning to write and direct Man of Tomorrow, set for release in 2027. While details about the new film remain under wraps, it is expected to continue portraying Corenswet’s Superman as a symbol of hope and non-toxic masculinity.
Looking Ahead: Supergirl’s Different Masculine Energy
Following Superman, DC’s next major project is the 2026 Supergirl film directed by Craig Gillespie and starring Milly Alcock. The post-credits scene of Superman hints at a notable contrast between Alcock’s rebellious, indifferent Supergirl and Gunn’s thoughtful Superman. This contrast suggests the upcoming film may offer a very different perspective on gender dynamics and masculine traits, departing from the gentle strength displayed by Corenswet’s hero.
As audiences await the new direction, the success of James Gunn’s Superman demonstrates a significant shift in how masculinity can be portrayed in superhero narratives—one that balances power with vulnerability and fosters a deeper emotional connection.
