Combining the talents of Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal in an R-rated romantic comedy has proven successful once again, as the film Materialists climbed to the top of HBO Max’s streaming charts shortly after its release. After making $108 million at the box office since its June 2025 debut, this Dakota Johnson rom-com streaming hit is drawing significant attention from viewers on the platform.
Materialists’ Journey from Theaters to Streaming Success
Materialists, written and directed by Celine Song, tells the story of Lucy, a driven New York City matchmaker caught in an emotional tug-of-war between a seemingly perfect new match and her complicated ex. With a production budget of $20 million, the film achieved moderate commercial success, becoming A24’s third-highest grossing movie ever. This performance follows Song’s previous success with her 2023 film, Past Lives, solidifying her rising presence in independent cinema.
Despite the financial success, critical and audience reception has been mixed. The film holds a 77% critics’ score but scored only 66% on Rotten Tomatoes’ Popcornmeter, as some viewers labeled it slow-paced and unengaging. Nonetheless, the streaming debut on HBO Max has sparked renewed interest, with millions tuning in to form their own opinions.
Mixed Audience Reactions to the Dakota Johnson Rom-Com Streaming Hit
Materialists divides opinion sharply among its viewers. For some, the film offers a thoughtful and realistic portrayal of love, deviating from typical romantic comedy tropes. A streaming viewer described it as
“Beautiful. Unexpectedly not as light as you originally suspect. It’s nice to see a love story with a dose of reality.”
This sentiment reflects appreciation for the film’s nuanced storytelling and emotional depth.
On the other hand, criticism targets several aspects including casting and pacing. Multiple reviews express disappointment with Dakota Johnson’s performance and the on-screen chemistry with Pedro Pascal. One critiques Johnson’s acting harshly:
“What an idiotic movie. I’d never seen Dakota Johnson in anything before but am stunned at what–not subpar or mediocre–but a really terrible actress she is. And zero chemistry with Pedro Pascal.”
Another review echoes these concerns, commenting on the story’s dullness:
This movie was an absolute snooze fest. The dull relationship connections, the drug out storyline and the overall plot was dismal at best. None of the actors came across as having any sort of rapport with one another.
Why Viewers Are Still Tuning In Despite Mixed Reviews
While critiques abound, the Dakota Johnson rom-com streaming success signals that many viewers are still intrigued by the film’s premise and performances. The film’s presence as HBO Max’s top movie illustrates a demand for romantic stories that engage with complex emotions, even if they divide opinion. Its R-rating and tone also set it apart from more formulaic rom-coms, offering something different to HBO Max’s audience.
For those uncertain whether Materialists is a good fit, the film may appeal to viewers seeking a romance that does not rely heavily on humor but instead emphasizes personal conflicts and realistic dynamics. With millions watching and discussing the film, it continues to generate conversation about what modern romantic comedies can explore on streaming platforms.
Key Cast of Materialists
The film features Dakota Johnson as Lucy, the young matchmaker at the heart of the story. Chris Evans plays John, while Pedro Pascal takes on the role of Harry, Lucy’s imperfect ex. The supporting cast includes Zoe Winters as Sophie, adding further depth to the narrative.
