Fans are wondering if Lizzy Caplan will reprise her role as Lula May in the upcoming film Now You See Me: Now You Don’t. The actress appeared on the red carpet alongside her co-stars on Monday, November 10, at the world premiere held at The Lighthouse at Chelsea Piers in New York City, generating speculation about her involvement in the third installment.
Star-Studded Cast Gathers for Premiere
At the event, Lizzy Caplan posed with fellow cast members Dave Franco, Woody Harrelson, and Jesse Eisenberg. Caplan had previously featured in Now You See Me 2 as a replacement for Isla Fisher, who was absent then but has returned for the third movie. Isla Fisher joined other stars such as Morgan Freeman, Rosamund Pike, Ariana Greenblatt, Dominic Sessa, Justice Smith, and director Ruben Fleischer for the premiere evening.
Hints and Reactions About Caplan’s Role in the New Movie
When speaking with ScreenRant earlier in February 2025, Lizzy Caplan seemed uncertain about the completion of Now You See Me 3’s production. Later, in a September 2025 interview with Entertainment Weekly, Jesse Eisenberg responded to questions regarding Caplan’s return, emphasizing the excitement of surprise moments in the film.
“I’ll put it this way. The surprise appearances in the movie are just as much fun as they are surprising. These are not boring appearances. It’s the best kind of shock because it’s a surprise but also done in such an unusual way.”
— Jesse Eisenberg, Actor
Anticipation Builds Ahead of Theatrical Release
The final trailer for Now You See Me: Now You Don’t was recently released, with the movie scheduled to open in theaters this Friday. Given the gathered cast and hints of unexpected cameos, audiences are eager to discover whether Lizzy Caplan’s Lula May will indeed make a memorable comeback in this much-anticipated sequel.
