The Matrix has become a landmark in science fiction cinema, with Keanu Reeves’ portrayal of Neo now almost inseparable from its identity. But the process of Keanu Reeves Matrix casting was a twisting journey, as the Wachowskis and Warner Bros. considered a variety of possible leads before finding the perfect fit for their dystopian hero.
Although Reeves is now synonymous with Neo, he was not the studio’s first pick, and the film’s legacy was shaped as much by those who were almost chosen to fill his role. Here is a detailed look at seven actors who came close to leading The Matrix, revealing just how different the film’s tone and cultural impact could have been.
The Road to The Matrix: Searching for Neo in Hollywood
When The Matrix launched as a franchise in 1999, few could have guessed that Keanu Reeves would become the defining face of cyberpunk rebellion. Before his casting, The Wachowskis and Warner Bros. took interest in several prominent stars, envisioning very different versions of the film’s protagonist. These casting considerations reflect not just the uncertainty of blockbuster filmmaking but the rapidly shifting winds of late ‘90s Hollywood trends and sensibilities.
The quest to cast Neo was a story of creative debate and industry pressure. With sci-fi and action exploding at the box office, Hollywood wanted a bankable star who could carry an ambitious franchise. However, The Matrix required more than just a leading name – it demanded an actor who could convincingly transform from an everyman into a figurehead of philosophical revolution.
Keanu Reeves was not an immediate or obvious choice, but in the end, his blend of understated intensity and relatable awkwardness allowed Neo to transition from office drone Thomas Anderson into “The One,” bridging the film’s strange digital universe and its high-concept ideas. Still, the shape of the film—and the franchise that followed—was nearly very different.
1. Will Smith: The Blockbuster Favorite Who Said No
Among all the alternatives to Keanu Reeves Matrix casting, Will Smith stands out as the most frequently remembered candidate. In the late 1990s, Smith was at the peak of his box-office power, headlining action hits like Independence Day, Men in Black, Bad Boys, and Enemy of the State. Studio executives believed that his magnetism would guarantee a successful franchise launch.
Smith ultimately passed on The Matrix. According to Smith, the film’s innovative ideas and signature “bullet time” visual effects were confusing on the page, and he was unconvinced by the pitch. He instead chose to star in Wild Wild West, missing the chance to help launch an entirely new sci-fi mythology. In retrospect, Smith’s high-energy style might have given Neo a more exuberant, crowd-pleasing tone, emphasizing cool charisma over philosophical alienation. Ultimately, the sense of disconnectedness and gradual awakening that Reeves established as Neo could have been lost, with Smith’s version shifting the movie toward pure spectacle rather than existential depth.
2. Val Kilmer: From Batman to Potential Matrix Lead
Val Kilmer’s proximity to the role of Neo has always seemed a bit surprising. As an established star, Kilmer was a versatile actor with credits ranging from Top Gun to Batman Forever. During the Matrix casting process, he was considered for both Neo and Morpheus, depending on how other negotiations played out.
If Kilmer had embodied Neo, his cautious, self-contained demeanor might have altered the character’s trajectory dramatically. Kilmer often projects a guarded intensity, and while that brings tension to many of his roles, it risked undermining Neo’s slow transformation from an uncertain individual to an icon of rebellion and self-discovery. His habit of staying emotionally opaque could have made the film’s early journey—where Neo must look lost and out of place—feel less authentic. In the end, Kilmer reportedly declined both roles to pursue other interests, and the complex mentor-student energy that defines Neo and Morpheus in the final film would have likely been colder and less inspiring with Kilmer involved.
3. Nicolas Cage: The Wild Card with Raw Intensity
Nicolas Cage’s inclusion on the list of almost-Neos demonstrates just how broad the studio’s search was. Cage has always brought a unique emotional intensity to his work, with characters frequently teetering on the edge of breakdown or eccentricity.
Had Cage led The Matrix, Neo might have appeared deeply unsettled right from the beginning, foregoing the film’s gradual unraveling in favor of immediate turmoil. Cage’s approach could have thrust the film into stranger territory, amplifying the surreal aspects of the story at the expense of its subtle progression. Still, Cage reportedly turned down the part for personal reasons, unwilling to relocate to Australia for the duration of filming, which ultimately prevented this wild and unpredictable take from ever becoming reality.
4. Brad Pitt: The Reluctant Superstar
Brad Pitt’s career in the ‘90s was defined by a string of dynamic performances, flooding the screen with charisma in films like Fight Club, Se7en, Interview with the Vampire, and 12 Monkeys. The producers offered him Neo, but Pitt felt the role was not a fit and declined.
Pitt’s movie-star persona, while magnetic, clashed with the character’s initial anonymity and vulnerability. The story of The Matrix hinges on a protagonist who blends into the background of a mundane life before being jolted into a world of unreality. Casting Pitt might have given the movie a smoother, more conventional blockbuster polish, pulling it away from the outsider energy that makes it unique. Pitt has since echoed the sentiment that he simply was not suited to playing Neo, and with his natural presence, the slow evolution of the character’s mythos would likely have been short-circuited from the start.
5. Leonardo DiCaprio: The Young Star Who Opted Out
Leonardo DiCaprio was another major name considered for Neo in the aftermath of Titanic’s colossal success. Despite the prospect, DiCaprio passed on the opportunity, reportedly concerned about the film’s heavy reliance on visual effects and feeling burned out from consecutive massive projects.
DiCaprio’s trademark is the depth of insecurity and emotional struggle he brings to his roles—qualities that could potentially have re-shaped Neo as a more overtly dramatic, troubled figure from the beginning. But Neo, as conceived by the Wachowskis, needs to start as an everyman, with myth and transformation developing gradually. DiCaprio’s innate screen presence might have overwhelmed the script’s demand for subtlety, making the film more about anguished heroics than about disconnection and rebirth. His withdrawal from the project preserved the story’s unique arc, letting the journey of self-discovery, rather than superstar intensity, take center stage.
6. Sandra Bullock: The Possible Female Neo
One of the most radical shifts ever considered in Keanu Reeves Matrix casting was the idea of transforming Neo into a female lead, with Sandra Bullock as the studio’s top choice. Bullock, already a star, was reportedly offered the part, and the script would have been rewritten to accommodate the change if she had accepted.
Producer Lorenzo di Bonaventura has since remarked on the level of resolve within the studio to secure a major lead, even if it meant rewriting core aspects of the film. Bullock, however, declined, and discussions did not proceed. If Bullock had played Neo, the dynamics between Neo, Morpheus, and Trinity would have undergone significant transformation, and the film’s broader social resonance could have shifted toward gender representation and new forms of audience identification. Her combination of warmth and accessible humanity would have recast Neo as an empathetic hero, leading to a very different kind of blockbuster and opening the door for more female-led action in the era.
7. Johnny Depp: The Wachowskis’ First Choice
Perhaps the most surprising revelation about The Matrix’s casting saga is that Johnny Depp was reportedly the Wachowskis’ initial preference for Neo. Depp, known for offbeat roles in Edward Scissorhands, Ed Wood, Sleepy Hollow, and Donnie Brasco, embodied the kind of disconnection and introspection the filmmakers sought at the time.
With Depp in the lead, The Matrix might have leaned even further into its surreal, philosophical side, emphasizing a protagonist caught between worlds, never fully at home. His artistic sensibility could have made Neo more enigmatic and unpredictable, foregrounding the film’s sense of unreality. Despite the Wachowskis’ enthusiasm, however, Warner Bros. did not want Depp in the primary role, and the project moved on.
How the Choices Shaped the Franchise’s Future
Each actor considered for Neo brought their own distinctive style and range, highlighting just how open-ended the casting process was and how easily the film could have become something else entirely. The studio’s willingness to shift gender, star power, and tonal direction reflected a desire to manufacture a hit while struggling to define exactly what The Matrix should be.
Ultimately, it was Keanu Reeves’ understated approach and grounded transformation that gave The Matrix its heart and enduring popularity. The collaboration between Reeves, the Wachowskis, and Warner Bros. locked in the film’s singular tone—a mood at once philosophical, strange, and emotionally overwhelming. This outcome speaks to the unpredictable nature of iconic casting: a role meant for someone else might eventually go to the only person who could do justice to the visionary demands of a genre-defining classic.
While alternate casting scenarios offer fascinating “what-ifs” for Hollywood enthusiasts and Matrix fans alike, it was the partnership of Reeves and the Wachowskis that transformed the film from an ambitious gamble into a cultural phenomenon. The very question of who could have been Neo shines a light on the power of casting to shape not only a story, but the legacy of an entire franchise—a legacy forever defined by one actor’s quiet charisma and stoic vulnerability.
20 Years Ago, The Matrix Got an Entirely New Ending That Many People Missed
