The debate over the Zack Snyder Superman box office legacy reignited after Snyder recently engaged with a social media post directly comparing his film’s financial performance to that of James Gunn’s fresh take on the superhero. This subtle interaction has prompted renewed comparisons between the two directors’ interpretations, as fans and industry observers dissected the meaning behind Snyder’s public move just months after Gunn’s Superman film concluded its theatrical run.
Snyder and Gunn’s Superman Films Face Box Office Comparison
Zack Snyder’s contribution to the Superman mythos, “Man of Steel,” premiered in 2013 and ultimately earned $670 million in global ticket sales. In contrast, James Gunn’s “Superman” (2025) recently finished its box office journey with $616 million. The proximity in earnings has fueled debates between diehard fans, each faction rallying behind their preferred creative vision for the iconic DC Comics character. The rivalry was further stoked when Snyder appeared to quietly align himself with those celebrating his film’s higher gross by liking an Instagram post from DC Brasil that contrasted the two movies’ performances on social media.
This online post went beyond total revenue, referencing both ticket sales numbers and average prices to suggest Snyder’s film outperformed Gunn’s in raw audience reach as well. Many within the Superman fandom interpreted Snyder’s Instagram activity as a tacit endorsement of the idea that “Man of Steel” outshone its successor, even if only by the numbers. Upon checking who acknowledged the post, fans saw Snyder’s handle among those who liked it—adding more fuel to ongoing discussions around which film deserves the Superman crown.
While there is no explicit statement from Snyder regarding the superiority of his version, observers have debated whether his digital engagement was simply a momentary nod or something more symbolic. As speculation circulated, some suggested this might indicate Snyder’s enduring attachment to his Superman legacy, although others noted the ambiguous nature of passive social media gestures.
Streaming Options and Upcoming Projects for Both Directors
For those wanting to revisit or compare the two visions, both “Superman” (2025) and “Man of Steel” are now available to stream via HBO Max. Meanwhile, James Gunn’s plans for the broader DC universe will progress with “Supergirl,” scheduled for theatrical release next year. Zack Snyder, on the other hand, is currently working on his next directorial venture, a war drama titled “The Last Photograph.” These separate paths reflect each filmmaker’s ongoing influence in the realm of DC properties, even as their Superman films continue to spark passionate debate.
No Evidence of Personal Rivalry Between Gunn and Snyder
The persistent box office debate has led some comic book fans to speculate about tension between the two directors. When the Snyderverse was discontinued in favor of Gunn’s new DC trajectory, online discourse sometimes veered toward claims of a personal or professional rift. However, public remarks from those involved and industry insiders suggest otherwise. According to reports, Zack Snyder has expressed good will toward Gunn and voiced optimism about the creative future of DC under Gunn’s guidance.
When James Gunn’s Superman reached theaters in July, he addressed the vocal, sometimes combative fan response, stating,
It’s all right to have an opposing force every once in a while.
— James Gunn, Director (via The Rolling Stone). Gunn has shown a willingness to accept criticism and opposition from Snyder’s dedicated supporters, taking it as part of the dynamic surrounding major franchise filmmaking.
Within the tight-knit community of Hollywood filmmakers, professional grudges are considered rare, especially among peers with shared creative challenges. Despite continued comparison from fans and media, both directors have maintained public decorum and, by most accounts, mutual respect. The divisive fandom discussions do not appear to represent any deeper conflict between Snyder and Gunn themselves.
The Lasting Impact of the Box Office Showdown
As the Zack Snyder Superman box office discussion continues to circulate online, comparisons between “Man of Steel” and “Superman” (2025) are unlikely to fade anytime soon. Snyder’s recent acknowledgment of fan debate via social media has kept the rivalry in the spotlight, but current evidence points to the conversation remaining mostly among fandom circles rather than escalating into a personal feud between the directors. With “Supergirl” and “The Last Photograph” on the horizon, both James Gunn and Zack Snyder are poised to shape the future of their respective filmographies, leaving the ultimate Superman debate to the fans and the box office history books.
https://twitter.com/_DCCBRASIL/status/1989678475976802558
