Intense speculation has erupted online over a perceived James Gunn Batman casting hint, following a cryptic interaction by DC Studios co-CEO James Gunn on social media. The incident has reignited fan debates about who might take on the role of Batman in the DCU, as official casting details remain elusive and The Brave and the Bold continues development without a public release date.
Unanticipated Social Media Engagement Raises Eyebrows
Discussion around the DCU’s next Batman has only increased as various fan-favorite candidates, including Brandon Sklenar and Alan Ritchson, have been proposed across social media forums. However, with Batman not expected to appear in the 2026 Clayface movie and The Brave and the Bold appearing to be far from production, fans believed answers remained distant—until Gunn’s recent activity provided new fuel for rumors.
This speculation was triggered when James Gunn posted an image of storyboards related to his follow-up Superman film, which is scheduled to begin filming in April. A fan replied to Gunn’s post by sharing a picture of Tom Brittney, one of the finalists for the recent Clark Kent casting, along with the caption, “Bruce says [merman emoji].” The merman emoji, regularly featured in Gunn’s posts and previously seen on Peacemaker, seemed an odd but potentially meaningful nod. Gunn’s direct reply—
“That guy is a great f—king actor!”
—drew immediate attention.
Although Gunn’s reply came in a thread with little engagement, its significance did not go unnoticed. James Gunn is known for his subtle teases of upcoming DCU developments, such as previously sharing Mister Terrific’s image online before the character’s involvement in Superman was revealed. Speculation therefore increased that his response may carry more weight than initially assumed.
Tom Brittney’s History With DC Studios Bolsters Speculation
Tom Brittney’s connection to DC Studios extends beyond the recent social media incident. He had been a top contender for the Superman role, competing alongside David Corenswet, who ultimately secured the part. Gunn has a history of keeping talented actors on his radar, often considering them for alternative roles if he is impressed by their auditions. A notable example is Nicholas Hoult, who was considered for Superman but was later cast as Lex Luthor.
In 2024, Gunn publically praised Brittney during a conversation on Threads when a fan inquired about the actor’s Superman audition attire.
Yes. Tom messed it up and then Corenswet came in and he was way too tall, so it just got torn to shreds. BTW, Tom is truly one of my favorite actors. Incredibly talented guy.
—James Gunn, DC Studios co-CEO
Given that Batman and Superman are often depicted with similar builds and features in the comics, the idea of a previous Superman hopeful eventually donning the cowl is not outside the realm of possibility.
James Gunn Acknowledges Having Candidates for Batman Role
James Gunn previously discussed his approach to casting DC’s major heroes. Speaking to The Ringer-Verse, he indicated that although he has clear preferences for certain actors, the final casting can surprise, as occurred with Superman.
I mean, do I have ideas about actors to play Batman? Absolutely, I do. I have guys I like. I have guys that are at the top of the list for me. Just like I had people that were at the top of the list for Superman. But […] those aren’t the people… they aren’t David Corenswet. So, they didn’t get the job.
—James Gunn, DC Studios co-CEO
This openness about his thought process leaves room for doubt and hope among fans, fueling further debate about whether Brittney, or another familiar face, will ultimately headline The Brave and the Bold.
What Gunn’s Actions Might Mean and Upcoming DCU Films
While it’s possible that Gunn’s comments were merely praise for Tom Brittney’s earlier audition performance, his selective reply to a post specifically linking Brittney with Batman stands out. Gunn often avoids addressing future DCU plans or directly engaging with posts suggesting alternate casting ideas, adding to speculation about the importance of his interaction.
The Brave and the Bold still awaits an official release date, leaving the role of Batman surrounded by uncertainty. However, Batman will return to cinemas in The Batman Part II on October 1, 2027. In the meantime, DCU’s next scheduled release is Supergirl, due to premiere on June 26, 2026.
With fan interest at a high point and speculation rampant following James Gunn’s social media activity, the question remains open: did Gunn’s recent online remark truly contain a hint about Batman’s next actor, or was it simply a public show of appreciation for Tom Brittney? Only time—and future studio announcements—will provide definitive answers.
— James Gunn (@JamesGunn) November 15, 2022
