Recent Marvel fan art has reignited speculation about the return of Tom Holland, Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield as alternate Spider-Men in the highly anticipated film, Avengers: Doomsday. As excitement grows in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the Tom Holland Avengers Doomsday Spider-Man reunion could mark a significant event, intertwining storylines from multiple realities and past films.
Renewed Hopes for a Spider-Man Trio in Doomsday
Since his introduction as Spider-Man in Captain America: Civil War, Tom Holland has become the MCU’s established Peter Parker. Looking ahead, Holland is set to anchor a new trilogy for the franchise, beginning with Spider-Man: Brand New Day, which is planned for release in 2026. The role of Spider-Man has seen other notable actors in the past, with Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield each taking on the iconic character in their respective series. Both Maguire and Garfield notably returned as their versions of Spider-Man for the first time alongside Holland in 2021’s Spider-Man: No Way Home.
Their alliance created a multiverse-spanning adventure, with the trio battling a range of villains brought from alternate dimensions into the world known as Earth 616. As No Way Home came to a close, Maguire and Garfield were sent back to their home universes, but the film’s events left the door open for potential future appearances in the MCU’s evolving multiverse narrative. Speculation about their return heightened when new, dramatic Avengers: Doomsday fan art from @spdrmnkyxxiii on Instagram went viral, inspiring discussions online about what such a crossover could mean for the franchise.
What Makes Maguire and Garfield’s Return Possible
Despite no official confirmation that Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland will feature together in the cast of Avengers: Doomsday, their combined presence would offer continuity and excitement for fans. The Russo brothers are attached to this major Marvel crossover, building anticipation for how these familiar Spider-Men might be woven into the plot. Tom Holland’s next standalone outing is set for July 2026, just months before the scheduled December premiere of Avengers: Doomsday, fueling theories that events from his new movie could set up his involvement in Doomsday’s storyline.
Adding complexity to the plot, Robert Downey Jr. is reportedly taking on the mantle of Doctor Doom. Given Peter Parker’s connection to Tony Stark as a mentor in the earlier MCU films, fans have expressed interest in how Holland’s character would handle facing a villain bearing the face of his late guide. The setup could lead to emotionally charged moments and significant character growth for Holland’s Spider-Man. Many of these ideas have circulated among fans who continue to analyze every Marvel announcement for clues.
Expanding the Multiverse: Doctor Doom’s Reality-Spanning Threat
Avengers: Doomsday is set to explore the dramatic consequences of the multiverse, with Doctor Doom attempting to avert destruction by traveling to different realities. Starting on the Fantastic Four’s Earth 828, Doctor Doom’s journey is likely to include the Illuminati’s Earth 838, the X-Men’s Earth 10005, and eventually Earth 616, which serves as the primary MCU continuity. Each Spider-Man variant helmed by Maguire and Garfield exists in their own universes: the Sam Raimi Spider-Man trilogy universe, known to fans as Earth 96283, and the Amazing Spider-Man series’ Earth 120703, respectively. This narrative makes it plausible for Doctor Doom to encounter both versions during his quest.
The fallout from Spider-Man: No Way Home also contributes to the stakes. That film ended with five villains being healed and returned to their original universes, fundamentally altering those timelines. The resulting timeline changes could trigger multiversal incursions—an existential threat Doctor Doom seeks to prevent, potentially providing a unifying reason for the Spider-Men to join forces again. While Andrew Garfield has denied involvement in the new film, echoing his stance before No Way Home, Tobey Maguire has not publicly commented on his potential return, adding further intrigue to the rumor mill.
A Crossover of Heroes and Legacies
Marvel’s exploration of the multiverse not only makes these crossovers narratively possible but also honors the legacy of Spider-Man in cinema. Bringing together Tom Holland, Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield would unite different generations of fans while providing opportunities for character-driven storytelling. The concept of multiple Spider-People working together against Robert Downey Jr.’s Doctor Doom offers fresh dynamics and could bring new emotional resonance as they face altered realities and the consequences of past battles.
As fans await further announcements and official casting confirmations, speculation continues to stir across platforms and fan forums.
“Every Spider-Man Suit Tom Holland Has Worn in the MCU”
—Tom Holland, Spider-Man—remains a talking point among viewers eager to see which version of the character might appear if such a crossover comes to fruition.
What Lies Ahead for the Spider-Man Franchise
The Marvel Cinematic Universe stands at the brink of another transformative chapter as rumblings about Tom Holland, Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield’s return continue to grow. A storyline involving realities, incursions, and a multiversal villain heightens expectations for Avengers: Doomsday, particularly for fans invested in the fates of Peter Parker and his variants. With the next Holland-led movie debuting in July 2026 and Avengers: Doomsday set for December, the stage is set for possible overlaps and narrative setups connecting both films.
Marvel is known for its secrecy, and a confirmed appearance from Maguire or Garfield remains to be seen, keeping excitement high until official news arrives. For now, the possibility of these three Spider-Men confronting Robert Downey Jr.’s Doctor Doom in a battle across the multiverse is fueling anticipation, discussion, and vibrant fan creativity—ensuring Spider-Man’s legacy, in all its forms, continues to captivate audiences.
