Andrew Garfield, recognized as one of his generation’s most talented actors, has crafted an impressive filmography over nearly two decades, captivating audiences worldwide. Known especially for his role as Peter Parker in The Amazing Spider-Man franchise, his dedication earned him numerous honors including a Tony Award and multiple Oscar and Emmy nominations. This article explores the best Andrew Garfield movies, ranked by IMDb scores, highlighting his versatility across various genres and styles.
An Experimental Mystery: Under the Silver Lake (2018)
Under the Silver Lake divides opinion due to its enigmatic and unconventional narrative. Directed by David Robert Mitchell, who is known for the cult hit It Follows, the film offers a more complex and puzzling storyline than most of Garfield’s work. While some viewers find the plot confusing, Garfield’s performance remains the shining aspect, consistently engaging the audience despite the film’s polarizing reception.
A Look Inside a Televangelist’s Life: The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021)
In 2021’s The Eyes of Tammy Faye, Garfield embraced a more intimate, smaller-scale project, differing from his blockbuster ventures. Directed by Michael Showalter, who also helmed The Big Sick, this biographical drama examines the life of Tammy Faye Bakker, portrayed by Jessica Chastain. Garfield’s participation in this indie-style film reflects his willingness to explore diverse roles beyond mainstream audiences’ expectations.
The Bigger Budget Sequel: The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014)
The Amazing Spider-Man 2 followed its predecessor’s moderate success with increased production investment, becoming one of the priciest Spider-Man films alongside Spider-Man 3. Markedly different in tone, this sequel featured a more playful and comedic Peter Parker, which some viewers found jarring compared to the original’s mood. Nevertheless, the movie stood out for its exceptional visual effects, considered among the best in the Spider-Man series.
A Surreal Visual Journey: The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (2009)
This visually striking and fantastical movie, directed by Terry Gilliam, is notable for featuring one of the last significant performances from Heath Ledger. The film navigates a dreamlike narrative with Ledger’s role completed by different actors after his untimely death, a move that was praised for its respectful execution. Despite mixed opinions about the plot, its stunning imagery and creative sequences have earned it a unique place in Garfield’s filmography.
Reimagining Spider-Man: The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)
After Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy concluded, Sony rebooted the franchise with Marc Webb directing The Amazing Spider-Man, which introduced Garfield in the lead role. The film retells Peter Parker’s origin story, and although the plot received mixed reviews, Garfield’s chemistry with Emma Stone elevated the film significantly. His portrayal was widely praised, sparking debates that considered him one of the best actors to have taken on Spider-Man, a reputation bolstered by his performance in Spider-Man: No Way Home.
A Contemporary Romantic Drama: We Live in Time (2024)
Among Garfield’s recent releases, 2024’s We Live in Time stands out with an emotionally charged performance alongside Florence Pugh. Their on-screen relationship brings a fresh dynamic, comparable to Garfield’s earlier chemistry with Emma Stone. The film’s heartfelt and poignant storytelling, paired with beautiful visuals, makes it a noteworthy entry in his recent work, though its emotional depth might make it a challenging re-watch for some.
A British Sci-Fi Tragedy: Never Let Me Go (2010)
Never Let Me Go is a British dystopian romantic tragedy based on the novel of the same name. Set in an alternate England, it follows three friends—Kathy, Ruth, and Tommy—whose complex relationships unfold amid a dark secret regarding their existence. The film performed well in the UK and has since become a modern sci-fi classic, earning acclaim for Garfield’s subtle yet compelling role among co-stars Keira Knightley and Carey Mulligan.
A Compelling Tale of Survival: 99 Homes (2014)
Directed by Ramin Bahrani, 99 Homes tells the story of Dennis Nash, who finds himself entangled in morally complex decisions as he helps evict families to save his own home. Featuring Michael Shannon and Laura Dern, the film faced modest box office success due to its heavy themes. However, it received strong praise at film festivals, with particular commendation for Garfield’s powerful performance and his ability to embrace roles away from typical mainstream fare.
A Story of Resilience and Love: Breathe (2017)
Andy Serkis’ directorial debut, Breathe, depicts the true story of Robin Cavendish, who lives with polio-induced paralysis. The film explores his defiance of grim medical predictions alongside his evolving relationship with his wife. Garfield’s portrayal drew acclaim, with The Guardian’s Mark Kermode noting the intensity in his eyes during moments of despair, capturing the raw human spirit of a man fighting against fate.
“There’s a real terror in Garfield’s eyes as Robin stares into the abyss, spitting in the face of a hospital chaplain who announces that his suffering was somehow part of God’s plan.”
– Mark Kermode, Film Critic
Exploring Faith and Perseverance: Silence (2016)
In Martin Scorsese’s Silence, Garfield plays Sebastião Rodrigues, a Jesuit priest on a perilous journey to Japan seeking his mentor, who may have renounced the faith. The film examines themes of belief, persecution, and survival under feudal oppression. Garfield prepared extensively for this demanding role by studying with Father James Martin, shedding significant weight and spending time in silent retreats to fully inhabit his character’s spiritual struggles, resulting in one of his most praised performances.
Andrew Garfield’s Enduring Appeal and Future Prospects
Andrew Garfield’s distinguished career spans a wide range of genres, from major franchise blockbusters to intimate indie dramas, illustrating his dynamic range and dedication to acting. His performances are often the highlight of his films, earning him respect from critics and fans alike. As he continues to take on diverse roles alongside esteemed colleagues such as Florence Pugh and Jessica Chastain, Garfield remains a powerful force in contemporary cinema, with many eagerly anticipating his upcoming projects.
