Aubrey Plaza’s Forgotten Comedy Hits Netflix Charts Again

Aubrey Plaza comedy movie fans are seeing renewed interest in the film Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates, which has climbed to number four on Netflix’s charts since its addition to the streaming platform. This resurgence comes nearly a decade after its original theatrical release, bringing new attention to the mid-budget comedy starring Plaza alongside Zac Efron, Anna Kendrick, and Adam DeVine.

The movie follows two brothers, Mike and Dave, who place an online ad to find suitable dates for their sister’s wedding in Hawaii, hoping to prevent any embarrassment. Tatiana, played by Aubrey Plaza, and Alice, portrayed by Anna Kendrick, answer the ad with motives that lead to unpredictable and raucous situations. Directed by Jake Szymanski, known for HBO’s sports parody 7 Days in Hell, the film represents a style of comedy once frequently seen in theaters but often forgotten amid today’s fast-changing entertainment landscape.

Background and Context Behind the Film’s Initial Release

Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates was released by 20th Century Fox prior to Disney’s acquisition of the studio in 2019. This timing placed the film in a media environment very different from today’s streaming-dominated market, as it predated the major upheavals Hollywood experienced during the Covid-19 pandemic. When it hit theaters, the movie performed moderately, earning $77 million worldwide against a budget of $35 million.

Aubrey Plaza
Image of: Aubrey Plaza

The cast was a combination of talent riding waves of recent success: Adam DeVine and Anna Kendrick were gaining momentum from the popular Pitch Perfect 2, while Aubrey Plaza was wrapping up a seven-season run on the acclaimed TV show Parks and Recreation. Zac Efron was also coming off hits like Neighbors and its sequel. Despite strong individual profiles, the movie itself was a fairly standard entry in the comedy genre, which likely contributed to its initial fade from public attention.

The True Story That Inspired the Comedy’s Plot

The movie is inspired by actual events involving brothers Mike and Dave Stangle, who placed a Craigslist ad seeking dates for a wedding, an act that quickly captured the public’s imagination. This real-life stunt led to both book and movie deals, including a 2016 publication titled Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates: And a Thousand Cocktails, which coincided with the film’s release.

However, the film diverges significantly from the true story’s details, opting for broad comic exaggeration. Dave Stangle reflected on the unexpected viral success, saying,

We didn’t plan on this or see it coming at all. It was just another stupid thing we were posting online, and for some reason this one had the right ingredients to go viral,

to The Hollywood Reporter in 2016. The brothers themselves made cameo appearances in the movie at a Hawaii meet-and-greet party.

Director Jake Szymanski recalled the brothers’ on-set behavior, noting,

They showed up completely sunburned and drunk,

and added,

They have a little bit of that harmless buffoonery thing that’s enjoyable to watch.

Renewed Interest Due to Streaming and What It Means for Access

The film’s current prominence on Netflix highlights how streaming services can revive older titles and introduce them to new audiences long after their initial release. This dynamic reshapes how films receive attention and cultural relevance, offering a second chance for movies like Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates to find an enthusiastic viewership.

For those interested in owning a copy, the film is additionally available on Blu-ray and DVD through retailers such as Amazon, ensuring accessibility beyond streaming platforms. This accessibility may continue to fuel the movie’s popularity as viewers discover or revisit this lighthearted, adult-rated comedy featuring Aubrey Plaza and her co-stars.