The Elizabeth Olsen fantasy movie “Eternity” has rapidly become a leading streaming success as of 2025, thanks largely to Olsen’s reputation for selecting compelling narratives and delivering strong performances. Known primarily for her role as Wanda Maximoff in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Olsen also shines in this unique fantasy romantic comedy, captivating audiences and critics alike.
“Eternity” Dominates Apple TV+ Streaming Charts
In 2025, Elizabeth Olsen starred in “Eternity,” a fantasy romantic comedy that is currently the top-streamed movie on Apple TV+, surpassing titles such as “F1,” starring Brad Pitt, which holds the second spot according to FlixPatrol. Despite Apple TV+ focusing mainly on productions it has ownership over, “Eternity” has drawn significant attention, outperforming other Apple Originals like “The Gorge,” “The Family Plan,” “Highest 2 Lowest,” and “Ghosted.”
The film explores an imaginative afterlife, centering on Larry, an elderly man played by Miles Teller, who passes away after 65 years of marriage. When Larry arrives in the afterlife, he must select where to spend eternity—a choice that comes with permanent consequences. After picking a themed afterlife, he opts to wait for his wife Joan, portrayed by Olsen.
The story deepens when Joan also dies and reunites with Larry, only to discover her first husband, Luke, a Korean War casualty played by Callum Turner, has been waiting for her for 67 years. Torn between two men, Joan faces the profound challenge of deciding who she wishes to spend eternity with. Although the movie is rooted in fantasy, it ultimately examines the complexities of love and the idea that enduring hardships may carry deeper meaning than a fleeting passionate romance.
Critical Acclaim and Audience Praise for Elizabeth Olsen’s Role
“Eternity” has won praise from film critics, earning a Certified Fresh rating with a 76% score on Rotten Tomatoes, and an even higher audience score of 90%, which is classified as Certified Hot. The film’s blend of romantic comedy and fantasy elements sets it apart in the genre, attracting fans who appreciate innovation within conventional rom-com storytelling.
Produced by A24, the film diverges somewhat from the studio‘s usual offbeat fare while still maintaining a distinctive style. It received a Critics Choice Award nomination for Best Comedy, solidifying its recognition among industry professionals. Additionally, Miles Teller was honored with the Distinguished Performance award at the Savannah Film Festival, and Da’Vine Joy Randolph earned the Best Comedic Performance accolade from the San Diego Film Critics Society.
The Film’s Impact and What It Means for Elizabeth Olsen’s Career
The success of “Eternity” demonstrates Elizabeth Olsen’s versatility beyond her Marvel roles, reinforcing her status as a talented actress who embraces complex and original projects. Her ability to draw viewers to a streaming platform and earn critical acclaim underscores her growing influence within the film industry.
Given the positive reception from audiences and critics, “Eternity” is likely to bolster interest in fantasy-infused romantic comedies and encourage studios like A24 to continue backing innovative storytelling. For fans of Olsen and the genre, this film represents an engaging and thoughtful exploration of love across time and existence, setting a high bar for similar projects in the future.
