Hulu has officially greenlit a pilot for Ryan Coogler’s interpretation of The X-Files, with Coogler writing and directing, and Danielle Deadwyler cast in a leading role. This development has sparked intense discussions among fans of the original series, known for its slow-burn suspense, memorable flashlight scenes, and Mark Snow’s unforgettable theme music, about whether this new version should serve as a continuation or a fresh reboot of the beloved franchise.
The new series is described as centering on
“two highly decorated but vastly different FBI agents”
who form an unlikely bond while investigating cases involving unexplained phenomena in a long-closed division. This description deviates somewhat from the original storyline, which followed Agent Dana Scully (Gillian Anderson) being assigned to debunk paranormal claims made by Agent Fox Mulder (David Duchovny).
Arguments for Continuing the Original X-Files Universe
One of the strongest reasons to maintain continuity with the original series lies in preserving its rich legacy. Setting the new show within the established universe opens the door for the return of original cast members, a prospect that excites many longtime viewers. Gillian Anderson has reportedly spoken with Ryan Coogler and has not dismissed the possibility of reprising her role. Such appearances would deepen the connection between the original and the new series.
Fans envision Dana Scully as a mentor figure for new agents, perhaps with a retired but still determined Fox Mulder emerging to provide critical insights. Walter Skinner’s continued presence as a stabilizing force in the FBI would be welcome, as would a return of the Cigarette Smoking Man, whose mysterious presence is iconic to the franchise. These elements are central to The X-Files’ identity, and including them could reinforce the emotional investment built over decades.
The alien colonization storyline, the black oil parasite, and the Syndicate conspiracy form an integral part of the mythology that many fans hold dear. Discarding this foundation might risk alienating viewers who have followed the intricate plot threads through years of episodes and revival seasons.
Reasons to Opt for a Complete Reboot Instead
Conversely, some argue that the original alien mythology became overly complicated, especially during later seasons and revivals, which layered mysteries in a manner that confused even dedicated watchers. The narrative complexity sometimes undermined clarity, although fans largely tolerated it because of their fondness for Mulder and Scully.
A reboot would free Ryan Coogler to create a new mythology from scratch, allowing fresh storytelling without the burden of previous plotlines. This approach could attract new viewers who may not be familiar with years of backstory, making the show more accessible.
Creative freedom is a major factor here. Being tethered to decades of canon restricts the ability to innovate in design, narrative, and tone. Every deviation risks backlash from fans fiercely protective of continuity, a struggle notably seen in other franchises like Star Trek. A canonically separate X-Files series could maintain the franchise’s tone while enabling new directions and fresh ideas, unencumbered by fan expectations tied to the past.
Even if the mythology differs, incorporating classic “monster-of-the-week” episodes could satisfy viewers craving mystery and suspense without the complications of inherited conspiracies.
Exploring a Middle Ground: The Soft Reboot Approach
A possible compromise is a soft reboot, blending elements of both continuity and renewal. This would involve introducing new agents in the same universe with a lighter connection to existing mythology, while including legacy characters in cameo roles. This approach acknowledges the past without fully committing to it, balancing respect for long-term fans and the need to attract fresh audiences.
Though a theoretically safe choice, a soft reboot risks falling short for both groups by not fully satisfying either die-hard followers eager for deep lore or newcomers looking for a clear, independent narrative.
Regardless of direction, Ryan Coogler’s X-Files presents an opportunity to explore how conspiracy culture has transformed since the original show dominated 1990s television. While the prior series thrived on government secrecy and UFO paranoia, today’s reality includes official acknowledgments of unidentified aerial phenomena and widespread misinformation amplified by social media, turning conspiracy theories into mainstream narratives. Coogler’s series could investigate how people seek truth in an age when many believe they already possess it.
The question remains open: should Ryan Coogler’s X-Files continue the original storyline or reinvent itself entirely as a reboot?
