Friday, December 26, 2025

James Gunn’s Justice League Reboot: Who Should Play Missing Members?

With David Corenswet’s Clark Kent/Superman debuting in theaters, James Gunn is laying the groundwork for a new Justice League within the DC Universe. This fresh franchise has already introduced key characters such as Mister Terrific, Metamorpho, and Hawkgirl, while upcoming projects like Lanterns, The Brave and the Bold, and a Wonder Woman reboot promise to further expand the team. As anticipation grows, fans and creators alike are eager to discuss potential actors for the Justice League’s remaining iconic members.

Casting Prospects for the Justice League’s Core Heroes

Since the casting choices so far have garnered positive attention for their authenticity and skill, speculation about who might portray important figures like Wonder Woman, Martian Manhunter, Aquaman, The Flash, and Batman has become a vibrant topic. The DC Universe not only demands talent capable of action and charisma but also artists who can bring unique depth and nuance to these legendary characters. Below are some inspired suggestions for actors who could embody these heroes and enrich the new Justice League.

Katy O’Brian as Wonder Woman: Strength Coupled with Emotional Depth

Katy O’Brian has impressed audiences with her gripping performance in Love Lies Bleeding, showcasing not only physical prowess but also a touching vulnerability. For the role of Diana Prince, her ability to deliver intense fight sequences alongside genuine emotional moments makes her an excellent candidate. O’Brian naturally carries the commanding presence necessary to portray Wonder Woman as a fierce warrior with a relatable heart, bringing both strength and sensitivity to the character.

James Gunn
Image of: James Gunn

Colman Domingo Envisioned as Martian Manhunter: Gravitas and Voice Power

The elusive Martian Manhunter requires a performer whose voice commands attention and whose screen presence conveys deep experience and wisdom. Colman Domingo fits this description perfectly, able to stand out even when extensive makeup or CGI alters an actor’s appearance. His mastery of performance would grant this cosmic hero a solid gravitas, a quality that has been missing in live-action portrayals. Domingo’s own desire to craft a distinctive comic book role aligns with the potential of bringing Martian Manhunter fully to life in the DC Universe for the first time.

Dev Patel as Aquaman: A Fresh and Serious Ruler of the Seas

With Jason Momoa transitioning to play Lobo, the Aquaman role calls for a reinvention rather than repetition. Dev Patel offers a compelling alternative with his intense commitment and ability to convey depth and authority. Unlike Momoa’s energetic and carefree portrayal, Patel could embody the ocean’s king with a serious, dignified persona that commands respect. His dedication to any role, combined with imaginative interactions alongside digital creatures beneath the waves, promises a powerful Aquaman for this new era.

Austin Abrams as The Flash: Bringing Physicality and Emotional Complexity

The Flash’s identity within the DC Universe remains in flux, especially with Barry Allen’s previous portrayals by Ezra Miller and Grant Gustin still fresh in viewers’ memories. If Gunn’s team decides to continue with this iteration, Austin Abrams emerges as a strong candidate. After impressing audiences with his intense physical performance in the horror film Weapons, Abrams demonstrates the skill necessary to capture The Flash’s speed, emotional vulnerability, and humor. His ability to deeply engage viewers in high-stakes situations positions him well to energize this beloved character.

Jake Gyllenhaal’s Potential as Batman: Balancing Madness and Mentorship

Jake Gyllenhaal has increasingly gravitated toward action roles, recently featuring in titles like Road House, Ambulance, and Spider-Man: Far From Home. His growth as an actor and capacity for portraying complex emotions could make him a superb Bruce Wayne. Gyllenhaal’s knack for mixing intensity and a touch of unpredictability aligns him with predecessors such as Michael Keaton and Robert Pattinson, who revealed Batman’s intricate balance between controlled crime-fighter and a restless, sometimes unhinged protector. His chemistry with Damian Wayne as Robin also enhances his suitability for the role, blending paternal concern with a fierce determination to fight crime.

Building the Future of the DC Justice League

James Gunn’s Justice League reboot is poised to redefine the superhero team for a new generation by combining strong storytelling with inspired casting choices. The current slate of characters and the proposed actors for missing members promise a dynamic franchise full of artistry and emotional heft. As Superman’s new chapter unfolds in theaters, audiences can look forward to an increasingly cohesive universe where legendary heroes gain fresh interpretations. The careful selection of performers like Katy O’Brian, Colman Domingo, Dev Patel, Austin Abrams, and Jake Gyllenhaal promises a revival of the Justice League that’s both faithful to its roots and boldly reimagined for the future.

“Superman Broke a DCU Rule Before We Even Knew it Existed”

—Anonymous