Critics Clash on The Wrecking Crew, Praise Momoa and Bautista

The upcoming buddy cop movie The Wrecking Crew, starring Jason Momoa and Dave Bautista, is set to premiere on January 28, 2026, through Amazon Prime Video. The film centers on two estranged half-brothers, James and Jonny Hale, played by Bautista and Momoa respectively, who must come together to solve the mystery surrounding their father’s murder. With the keyword Jason Momoa Wrecking Crew driving interest, early screenings have ignited a variety of critical responses, highlighting both the leads’ chemistry and the film’s uneven narrative.

A Closer Look at the Plot and Performances

In the film, James and Jonny represent two contrasting personalities; one is impulsive and volatile, while the other is a highly disciplined Navy SEAL. Despite their differences, they unite to unravel a family tragedy, blending action and comedic elements. Jamie Parker of CBR gave the film a 7 out of 10 rating, emphasizing the leads’ dynamic as one of the movie’s strongest points. Parker observed that while the plot itself is nothing groundbreaking, the movie offers a throwback to classic 1980s-style action flicks with excitement and fun. Parker wrote,

“The Wrecking Crew gives fans exactly what they would expect going into the movie. It is a fun popcorn flick that delivers adrenaline-fueled fun, a buddy cop dynamic, and great performances from Momoa and Bautista. While the plot may fail to impress, it still makes for a comfortable easy-to-stream movie that hearkens back to the simpler action films of the 80s.”

Similarly, Greg Hermanns from ScreenRant also awarded the film a 7 out of 10, praising the chemistry between Bautista and Momoa as the main reason the movie remains entertaining despite an unoriginal storyline and limited character development. Hermanns noted the director Ángel Manuel Soto’s slick direction helped maintain the film’s momentum. He commented,

Jason Momoa
Image of: Jason Momoa

“The combination of [Ángel Manuel Soto’s] slick direction and nice chemistry between Bautista and Momoa ultimately keep The Wrecking Crew mostly afloat. It’s great to see the Guardians of the Galaxy alum play a more reserved character, yet still find the humor in such a part, while Bautista cutting loose is always a blast. Plus, while the Prime Video [offering] largely wraps things up for the Hale brothers, there’s just enough wiggle room for a potential follow-up to learn from some of the first movie’s missteps and improve upon the solid foundation.”

Mixed Opinions on Genre and Tonal Balance

Despite positive notes on the lead actors, some critics voiced concerns about the film’s uneven tone, which shifts awkwardly between action, comedy, and family drama. Giovanni Lago of Next Best Picture rated the movie 4 out of 10, criticizing the director’s failure to balance humor with the emotional stakes. Lago suggested the movie recycles familiar buddy cop tropes without adding fresh energy, writing,

“Is The Wrecking Crew a watchable experience? Depending on who is asked, it’s due mainly to Bautista and Momoa’s chemistry, or more to the attempt to find it. How often can we retread the same ground with this type of 48 Hours comedy duo before it becomes an annoyance? Maybe we’ve already passed that point. … Here, The Wrecking Crew simply relegates itself to the walls of screensaver cinema, destined to be ambient background noise.”

Jacob Oller of Paste also pointed out the film’s struggle to settle on a consistent tone, awarding it a grade of D+. Oller argued that the movie’s refusal to fully embrace either dumb humor or serious drama leaves the audience disconnected. Describing the film as wandering through many genres with limited success, Oller wrote,

“[Bautista and Momoa] put their personae and pectorals to work in the action-comedy, playing beefy bickering half-brothers doling out juvenile jokes and hardcore violence in equal measure, though never skewing far enough in either direction… Instead, The Wrecking Crew casts about between genres like driftwood caught by the tide; for two hours, the script cycles between family trauma drama, goofy Hawaiian noir, meathead romp, and wham-bang slugfest. The indecision at least showcases some consistency, though, in that each approach is equally dissatisfying.”

Action Sequences and Cinematic Presentation

Pete Hammond from Deadline highlighted the intense physicality displayed by Momoa and Bautista, noting that both actors prepared rigorously for their roles. Hammond suggested that The Wrecking Crew might have benefited from a theatrical release to fully showcase its action scenes and Hawaiian backdrop. He emphasized the chemistry and authenticity in their performances, stating,

“Both stars are in their sweet spot with this material and manage to handle not just the huge action quotient here, but also make it believable that in the end Johnny and James are just family, hale and hearty.”

What Fans Can Expect When Streaming Begins

While opinions on the storyline and tone are divided, critics largely agree that the pairing of Jason Momoa and Dave Bautista is the movie’s biggest draw. Their dynamic as bickering half-brothers offers enough entertainment to engage viewers seeking a straightforward action-comedy. The Wrecking Crew’s availability on Amazon Prime Video from January 28 makes it accessible for audiences looking to enjoy an adrenaline-fueled, if imperfect, buddy cop adventure. Given the hints of a possible sequel, this film may lay the groundwork for future improvements and continuing the story of the Hale brothers.